comScore

57: Black Sheep's Meatball, Ricotta, and Garlic Pizza

Do you remember when pizza was pizza? This was before you could choose between a BBQ Chicken with Banana Peppers and a Mock Duck Ginger Hoisin. And way before anyone dreamed up the Doritos Crunchy Crust (yes, that is a thing). While our crazy free market economy of pizza is entertaining, what happens when you want to kick it old school?

See also: 58: Poutine at Triple Rock

Enter Black Sheep's Meatball, Ricotta, and Garlic pizza. One taste of this perfect pie is like stepping into a portal that kicks you out onto New York's Spring Street circa 1905. The pizzaiolos of the Lower East Side used coal-burning ovens to darken their crusts, and Black Sheep follows in the same tradition. Over a hundred years later the technology hasn't changed much, and thankfully, neither have the results.

Black Sheep's crust walks the line. It's crisp, but not shatteringly so. It's thin, but will not buckle under the weight of ample toppings. Best of all, the crust is slightly blackened, but not pocked with burnt bubbles like so many wood-fired pizzas are prone to. You get just a taste of fire from its charred edges, instead of a mouthful of smoke.

Meatball, ricotta, and garlic make up the holy trinity of ingredients on this crust. With a slightly sweet, old-world tomato sauce as its base, the meatballs are thinly sliced and piled on, topped with clouds of fresh, milky ricotta cheese, thinly sliced garlic, and torn basil leaves. The pizza is deeply comforting, but not too simple. Just when you think you're indulging in a meat pizza with a capital M, a dollop of ricotta brings the flavors back into balance. It's a pizza that would make a paisano proud.

100: The Pickle Dog from the Minnesota State Fair 99: Mademoiselle Miel's Honey Bon-Bons 98: Giant Pretzel at New Bohemia 97: Kopplin's Breve 96: Corn Chowder at Barrio 95: Crescent Moon's House Special Football-Shaped Pizza 94: Buffalo Tots at the Blue Door Pub 93: Duck Burger at the Happy Gnome 92: Mac's Industrial Tuna Melt 91: Toast Bar at Canteen 90: Sonora Grill's Eggplant Fries 89: Brasa's Pineapple Ginger Ale 88: The Freehouse's Cheese Curds with Quince Jam 87: Black Coffee and Waffle Bar's Naughty Waffle 86: Czar Jack at Town Hall Brewery 85: Soft-Shell Crab Fried Rice at Tiny Diner 84: Sanduche de Pollo at Chimborazo 83: Grand Café's Eggs en Cocotte 82: Pollo Tacos at Las Teresitas 81: Chicken Tikka Masala at Himalayan Restaurant 80: Cornmeal Galette with Ham and Sweet Corn from Black Walnut Bakery 79: Cheddar Biscuits and Gravy at the Third Bird 78: The Buttermilk Chicken Sandwich at Lake and Irving 77: The Larry from Taco Cat 76: Lobster and Eggs from Eat Street Social 75: New York Strip with Trumpet Royale Mushrooms from Sparks 74: Icehouse's Sipping Shots 73: The Prairie Dog at Prairie Dogs 72: Dr. IPA at Public Kitchen & Bar 71: Patisserie 46's Éclair 70: Dong Hae's Korean Style Chicken Wings 69: Birchwood's Black Bottom Coconut Cream Pie 68: Coup d'Etat's Gnocchi 67: Egg, Cheddar & Bacon Biscuit Sandwich at Colossal Cafe 66: Red Wagon Pizza's Sausage Espagnole 65: Verdant Tea's Chinese Hash 64: The St. Paul Cheese Shop's Chorizo Sandwich 63: House of Curry's Pol Roti 62: Goat Cheese Curds from the Curious Goat 61: Post-Dessert Dessert at Spoon and Stable 60: Table-Side Caesar Salad from the Salt Cellar 59: Nam-Khao from On's Thai Kitchen 58: Poutine at Triple Rock

Send your story tips to Hot Dish.