Will Al Franken take on Android too?

Steve Jobs, the object of Al Franken's ire.
Steve Jobs, the object of Al Franken's ire.

We took note yesterday that Sen. Al Franken has fired off a nastygram to Apple boss Steve Jobs over published reports that iPhones and iPads were tracking and storing the movements of their users for some purpose yet to be revealed.

Now we're wondering whether Franken is going to have to take on every smart phone running Google's Android operating system as well - a much bigger lake with a lot more fish to fry.

The Guardian reports that a Swedish programmer named Magnus Eriksson has figured out that an Android phone records locations of the last unique 50 mobile masts and the last 200 Wi-Fi networks with which it has communicated.

Is the Android watching you?
Is the Android watching you?

Unlike the iOS system on the Apple devices, which O'Reilly Radar says stores location data for up to a year, the ANdroid phones overwrite the data files as they fill up. These are overwritten, oldest first, when the relevant list is full. It is not yet known whether the lists are sent to Google. That differs from Apple, where the data is stored for up to a year.

Franken's letter to Jobs raised a series of uncomfortable questions about the privacy and security of iPhone/iPad users, and what Apple intends to do with the data (it still hasn't responded to the press reports).

But it's not clear whether this sudden publicity over cell phone tracking is really a big deal or not. Eriksson told The Guardian he thought the issue was being blown out of proportion. And network security writer Alex Levinson has published a long post asserting that Apple's tracking system is neither new nor nefarious.

Sponsor Content


All-access pass to top stories, events and offers around town.

Sign Up >

No Thanks!

Remind Me Later >