Who's on Third?
The Third Ward of Minneapolis is in the midst of a city council election in which the candidates reflect the ward's bifurcated demographics. East of the Mississippi River, the ward contains predominantly white, working-class neighborhoods that make up the bosom of blue-collar northeast Minneapolis. On the other side of the water, in north Minneapolis, the ward's predominantly black and immigrant communities struggle to surmount one of the city's most entrenched cycles of crime and poverty.
Until very recently, the Third Ward was represented by Joe Biernat, a moderate, DFL council member who, after being caught making an under-the-table deal for union plumbing work done on his home, had to be dragged kicking and screaming from office. Biernat resigned his post on November 21, shortly after being convicted of aiding and abetting theft, mail fraud, and making false statements to a federal agent.
Twenty candidates ran in the December 30 primary. The top two vote-getters will now square off in a special election on February 3: DFL endorsee Olin Moore, a 32-year-old Northeast resident who has spent nearly all of his adult life as an aide to U.S. Rep. Martin Sabo; and Don Samuels, a 53-year-old toy designer and community activist from North's besieged Jordan neighborhood.
On paper, the two candidates have nearly indistinguishable agendas. Both cite the need to reduce crime and enhance public safety as a top priority. Both say they want to promote economic development along the commercial corridors of West Broadway and Central Avenue Northeast, establish better communication with constituents, and deliver better value for basic city services. In terms of personal style and life experience, however, the two first-time candidates present a compelling contrast.
Samuels is a Jamaican immigrant and former corporate executive who moved into Jordan five years ago. As a member of the Jordan Livability Forum, he began working to stabilize the community. He first gained citywide notoriety in the wake of this summer's riot in the neighborhood, when he criticized police and city leaders for trying to quell tensions by soliciting outside help from members of the City Inc. and the Urban League rather than relying on grassroots groups in Jordan. Six months later, his campaign is fueled by an unabashed, almost religious belief that he has been chosen to lead.
"My presence in this race is not just an aberration of circumstances; it is a convergence of history and faith," he says, sitting at his dining room table. "I feel that fate has conspired for me to be here: as an African American, as an immigrant, as a husband and father of two children, and as a former single father who raised a child from three years old to 18 by himself. I have contemplated racial issues while existing in a mostly white world, and my neighbors are inspired by what I bring to the table.
"I never thought I would be saying something that could be framed by a cynic as being egotistical. But I see the problems we struggle with, and feel in my heart I have the answers."
Acknowledging the city's gaping budget deficit, Samuels says he'll argue that the Third Ward has needs that can't be ignored or shortchanged. He maintains, however, that his vision is as much about attitude and morality as economics. He talks about how three new houses have been built near his home because residents worked to rid the area of drug dealing and other crime; and how he just received a letter and a $100 contribution from a lawyer in Burnsville who is moving to the neighborhood. "That is a spiritual reaction, moving here. People want to do the greater thing. I think that I have the ability to reframe the context in such a way that people won't have to be forced to do the right thing. Fairness and justice will exist along with economic stimulation and balance."
While emphasizing that he "won't be parochial and leave the Northeast out," Samuels says that a similar sense of spiritual goodwill will spur residents east of the river to understand and endorse the need to make the revitalizing of north Minneapolis neighborhoods a priority. He also believes an attitude of mutual respect can go a long way toward alleviating police-community tensions in Jordan and other impoverished neighborhoods.
"We have to have strong policing and we have to have justice. And so at the same time I am saying to the guys on the corner, 'You will not sell drugs in my neighborhood. I have a cell phone and I am calling 911 right now,' I take the same position with the police. I say, 'You will not treat these boys as if they are not human beings.' And I'm not saying it in a nicer way; I am saying it in the same way I talk to the guys on the corner, with a respect and acknowledgment of their humanity."
Whether you regard Samuels's message as boldly inspirational, hopelessly naive, or something in-between, the tenor of his candidacy almost ensures a visceral reaction. By contrast, Olin Moore is running the sort of orthodox, meat-and-potatoes DFL campaign that has traditionally kicked up more votes than emotions in the Third Ward.
Moore quickly demonstrates an ability to stay "on message" regarding his priorities for the ward. "We can have grand ideas, but I think the basic things people expect and want are safe and clean streets, redevelopment that involves community input, and leaders who responsibly manage the city budget," he says over java at the Mill City Coffee Shop, located east of the river. Over the course of a 40-minute interview, he manages to restate that three-pronged platform eight times, never forgetting to add that the streets should be clean as well as safe.
Boyish and soft-spoken, Moore is self-aware enough to know the limitations of his style. "What it will take [to win] is being compassionate about a set of ideas and having a commitment to community. I have that commitment," he says, then grins shyly. "And I am trying to convince people I have that passion."
Moore is a party animal politically if not socially, the epitome of a DFL loyalist. State party chair Mike Erlandson was the best man at his wedding and hosted a fundraiser for him. At the Third Ward DFL convention in December, Moore, a relative unknown to the general populace, bested Kari Dziedzic, who herself owns a gold-standard last name among party regulars, for the council endorsement. Last fall, Moore briefly left Sabo and went to work on Janet Robert's campaign for U.S. Congress against Mark Kennedy in the Sixth District. It was a brutal, nasty race, with Robert launching a series of specious allegations against Kennedy that prompted the Pioneer Press to dub her "The State's Premier Mudslinger."
But, given a chance to criticize Robert's tactics, Moore is unrepentant. "I am not going to second-guess what we did. We came up with a game plan and we stuck with it. I think Janet was a good candidate running in a very difficult district that leaned Republican. I think that that district represents a lot of work we need to do as a party to talk to a lot of folks who I believe are Democrats in their heart but have stopped voting Democrat because they may not like everything they see coming from our party."
Moore, who emphasizes that he grew up in a labor household and also had a grandmother who was a union steward, is similarly steadfast in his support of the often maligned city labor force. "I have a problem with the bashing of city employees. I think they are not always understood or appreciated. The reality is that there are thousands of city employees who every single day go to work and do nothing more than try to do their job to the best of their ability." This is music to the ears of many voters in northeast Minneapolis, where fidelity to unions is still an electoral plus. Indeed, Moore's primary victory was due to his strength in precincts east of the river, which typically produce twice as many voters as the north Minneapolis neighborhoods that are Samuels's stronghold.
Samuels's supporters have sought to capitalize on the impression that Moore is simply a tool of the DFL "machine" by dubbing their candidate "the authentic community voice." Samuels has also received plenty of support from volunteers outside the Third Ward, though, who helped him engineer an ingenious plan to include absentee ballots as part of their door-knocking, which generated nearly half of his primary vote total. Both candidates are vulnerable to charges that they will not work to serve the entire ward: Samuels because he is so fixated on the problems and priorities of north Minneapolis, and Moore because his political lens frequently extends beyond the ward to broader city, state, and federal frames of reference.
But perhaps the biggest disappointment in the race thus far has been the unwillingness of either candidate to take specific positions on issues relevant to the ward as a whole. Both Samuels and Moore gave vague answers in response to how they would have voted on the city council's decision last fall to cap property taxes at eight percent a year over the next decade. Asked whether the Civilian Review Authority investigating allegations of police misconduct should be granted subpoena power--perhaps the most contentious issue facing the candidates--both men ducked the question.
"I don't know. That is my answer. I'd want to talk to the community a lot more about that and get more input," Moore replied. Samuels, who has made police-community relations a centerpiece of his campaign, simply grimaced, laughed uncomfortably, and said, "Aaarrgghh. Don't ask me that yet."
Voters deserve more specific answers before February 3.
Get the This Week's Top Stories Newsletter
Every week we collect the latest news, music and arts stories — along with film and food reviews and the best things to do this week — so that you’ll never miss City Pages' biggest stories.