Dead Man's Curve Ball
The fireplace mantel in Stew Thornley's Roseville home bears a tiny engraved metal band that reads "Mickey." The framed print of Yankee Stadium above the fireplace should be a dead giveaway, but it takes a moment for the joke to register: Mickey Mantle.
It's a nice touch, and there are plenty of other small acknowledgments of the homeowner's lifelong obsession with the game of baseball, but the place is hardly the museum one might expect, given Thornley's status as perhaps the most recognizable and respected local baseball historian and writer. There are copies of his various books on regional sports history, as well as the dozen-plus titles he has written for young readers. Still, it's clear Thornley isn't a real collector--at least not in any ordinary sense of the word. His is a tidy, streamlined obsession. The real booty from his years of rummaging in baseball's attic arcana is stashed away in the file folders in his impossibly neat basement office.
Baseball offers its hard-core fans plenty of nooks and crannies in which to explore their obsessions, from its innumerable historical and statistical angles to the cards, autographs, and myriad other physical artifacts it generates. Thornley certainly possesses a historian's passion for the game's minutiae (in a typical digression he might recall how former manager and player Cookie Lavagetto broke up Bill Bevens's no-hit bid with a two-out, ninth-inning double in the fifth game of the 1947 World Series, eight years before he was born) and a few odd bits of memorabilia (most notably a baseball signed by Mickey Mantle). But the actual tangible aspect of his collection is negligible. Rather, it's the product of the considerable time, money, and energy he has expended over the past five years tracking down baseball immortals where they're at their most accessible. Captive, even. Well--dead.
You see, Thornley is a collector of baseball graves. The 43-year-old author has visited and photographed the final resting places of 69 baseball Hall of Famers, not to mention those of numerous lesser lights. His pursuit of the humblest and most humbling of face time with his heroes has taken him to cemeteries all over the nation, often in search of a quarry unknown to the custodians thereof. He has paid his respects to Charles Albert "Chief" Bender in Roslyn, Pennsylvania, to Mickey Welch and Willie Keeler in Queens, New York, to Eppa Rixey in Milford, Ohio, to Negro League pioneer Rube Foster in Blue Island, Illinois. He has rambled in the New Cathedral Cemetery in Baltimore, the necropolis most dense with dead Hall of Famers (Joe Kelley, John McGraw, Ned Hanlon, and Wilbert Robinson are all buried there). Thornley has trekked to the gravesite of Mordecai Centennial Peter "Three Finger" Brown, whose name has been understandably abridged on his tombstone in Roselawn Memorial Park in Terre Haute, Indiana. He has left a pair of sneakers at Shoeless Joe Jackson's grave in Greenville, South Carolina. In Bradenton, Florida, Thornley, ever the observant baseball fan, noted the lovely symmetry existent between the graves of Bill McKechnie and Paul Waner; there, in the Manasota Memorial Cemetery, the two men are buried roughly 90 feet apart--the distance between the bases on a baseball diamond. And in Meeker, Oklahoma, Thornley gazed upon the words chiseled beneath Carl Hubbell's name and the usual arithmetic of mortality, words that must be inexplicable to anyone unfamiliar with the legacy of the man who reposes there: "The Meal Ticket."
A genial, understated character with the slightly rumpled look of a college professor who plays a lot of pickup basketball, Thornley offers few outward clues that might explain what some might consider a morbid fascination with graveyards. His wife Brenda Himrich, a safety manager with Metro Transit, shares some of her husband's passion for baseball and occasionally accompanies him on his excursions, but as for his grave obsession, she merely smiles and shrugs. "I find it amusing," she allows. For his part Thornley will acknowledge that the hobby is a curious one; he seems content to leave it at that. "I've always liked to travel," he ventures. "I've been to all 50 states, and this is something that gives journeys a little destination or purpose. Hunting down these graves involves a lot of exploration. It can become almost a detective game, and it frequently takes you into out-of-the-way places and neighborhoods in a city where you wouldn't otherwise go. Cemeteries are often old, and in rundown parts of town--cities usually have grown up around these graveyards. And in the middle of these teeming urban areas, you'll find these very peaceful places, oases of serenity and green space." The bottom line seems to be that Thornley's hobby offers as good an excuse as any for a road trip. Something to do between baseball games.
Though it's clear that the passion has snowballed in recent years, it had relatively innocuous roots: On a family vacation in 1966, Thornley's father took a detour off a Michigan highway to visit the grave of legendary Notre Dame football coach George Gipp in Calumet. The snapshot they took there now occupies the leadoff spot in his graveyard scrapbook slide show. Growing up in Minneapolis in the late Fifties, Thornley lead a life steeped in sports. His father was a former Stalag 17 prisoner who was an ardent baseball fan and a supervisor in the downtown post office, and his mother's faculty position at the University of Minnesota allowed her son access to all of the UM sports events.
"I was crazy about baseball right from the start," Thornley remembers. "I read everything I could get my hands on, anything to do with baseball history, and I think I drove my teachers crazy. I'm sure they thought that I would outgrow my interest in it, but I kept discovering that there were all these outlets to keep the interest alive. I became a writer not because I had this great desire to write, but because I had this tremendous interest in the subject."
As a kid he hung out at the university's baseball fields; in 1968 and 1969 he was the batboy for the Dick Siebert-coached Gopher teams that won back-to-back Big Ten championships. Throughout much of his childhood, he maintained a correspondence with Twins broadcaster Halsey Hall, whose biography he would later write. After high school he attended broadcasting school at Brown Institute, worked for a time in radio, went back to college, and got a job in business, but it wasn't until he discovered the Society for American Baseball Research in 1979 that he discovered a true outlet for his continuing interest in baseball. He began researching and writing On to Nicollet: The Glory and Fame of the Minneapolis Millers in 1980, and worked at it off and on for the next seven years. Local publisher Nodin Press released the book in 1988, and Thornley has been a busy writer ever since. These days he also has a job with the state of Minnesota, doing public-affairs work in the public drinking-water program, but he still finds plenty of time for his hobby.
Thornley's graveyard odyssey began, properly enough, with a visit to the grave of Alexander Cartwright in Oahu Cemetery in Hawaii, in 1995. (All Abner Doubleday malarkey aside, Cartwright was one of the true fathers of baseball, the man who helped draw up the original rules, organized the first games in New York in the 1840s--in the Elysian Fields, no less--and later introduced the sport to Hawaii.) Later that same year, Thornley followed up his visit to Cartwright's modest grave--which bears no mention of his baseball achievements--with a trip to Babe Ruth's resting place in the Gate of Heaven Cemetery in Hawthorne, New York.
He keeps a meticulous catalog of the graves he has visited, complete with addresses and phone numbers, cemetery plots, directions, and occasional entertaining asides. His entry for the Gate of Heaven is typical: "Babe Ruth, drunk and Hall of Famer, and Billy Martin, drunk, both in section 245." Gate of Heaven, incidentally, is part of a peculiar baseball necro-nexus: Just across the road is the Kensico Cemetery, where, amid the sprawling democracy of the dead that is any great cemetery, lie three Hall of Famers (including Lou Gehrig), as well as luminaries such as Danny Kaye, Ayn Rand, and Sergei Rachmaninoff. "Here's Rachmaninoff, decomposing in Kensico," Thornley quips, pointing out a photo of the composer's grave.
A lot of legwork goes into a typical Thornley graveyard junket, and he usually tries to organize his trip so he can take in major league games while he's on the road. The FindaGrave Web site (www.findagrave.com), to which he is a frequent contributor, is an essential resource tool. "Efficiency becomes very important," the collector notes. "I try to coordinate things so I can see as many graves as possible in a relatively short time. Once I find out where someone's buried, I'll try to send away for cemetery maps and directions. And by the time I hit the road, I'll have done all my preparation and I'll be ready to knock off a lot of them in one stretch."
On a recent trip to Florida, Thornley managed to cover both the Gulf and Atlantic coasts, crisscrossing the state several times in three days and logging 11 new Hall of Famer gravesites in the process. In Jacksonville's Evergreen Cemetery, the employee he stopped to ask for directions to Bill Terry's plot boasted, "I put him in there." In between his graveyard explorations, Thornley found the time to take in games in Tampa Bay and Miami, and also paid a visit to the Ted Williams Museum in Hernando.
Thornley will be the first to admit that he has sometimes allowed himself to get carried away. He has added the gravesites of dead presidents, celebrities, oddballs, and even racehorses (Man o' War, in Lexington, Kentucky) to recent itineraries. Among his photos are snapshots of the graves of Colonel Sanders, Hank Williams, Wyatt Earp, Duke Ellington, Edgar Allan Poe, and J. Edgar Hoover (at whose marker someone had left a pink bra and panties). He recently found himself making a 20-minute detour out of Baltimore to visit the grave of Spiro Agnew. Handing over the photo, Thornley shrugs. "I had to make sure he was dead, I guess."
Occasionally, however, he does draw the line. He recently passed up the opportunity to visit Lobster Boy's grave in Florida. Still, one senses a touch of regret in his voice when he says, "I missed Mr. Ed somewhere out in Oklahoma one time, but he was just too damn far off the interstate."
Get the This Week's Top Stories Newsletter
Every week we collect the latest news, music and arts stories — along with film and food reviews and the best things to do this week — so that you'll never miss City Pages' biggest stories.