|Zero Dark Thirty||11||13|
|Goodbye First Love||2||2|
|Silver Linings Playbook||2||2|
|God Bless America||1||1|
|Once Upon a Time in Anatolia||1||1|
|Oslo, August 31st||1||1|
|Paul Thomas Anderson, The Master||1||1|
|Richard Linklater, Bernie||1||1|
|The Cabin in the Woods||1||1|
|The Deep Blue Sea||1||1|
|This Is Not a Film||1||1|
|Damsels in Distress||0||1|
|The Loneliest Planet||0||1|
|Your Sister's Sister||0||1|
This year, 85 critics from across the country voted for their favorite films, performances, and filmmakers in 12 categories. For six of those categories (Best Film of the Year, Best Actor, Best Actress, Best Supporting Actor, Best Supporting Actress, Best Undistributed Film), critics had the option to either "rank" or "unrank" their votes. For example, in the Best Film category, where ten votes are possible, a ranked ballot's #1 choice was awarded 10 points, the #2 choice nine points, etc. On ballots designated as "unranked," films were awarded five points each, and performances two points. Ties of any kind were not allowed.
A film is eligible only in the year that it was first distributed in the U.S. For the category of Best Undistributed Film, only those films from the past 12 months that have yet to secure a theatrical distributor were eligible (as opposed to those films with distributors that simply won't be released until next year).