To Have and Have Not
The sexual chemistry between Bogie and Bacall in this 1944 classic turns a movie that might have been merely amusing into a historic event. To Have and Have Not—about two streetwise drifters who fall in love on a Caribbean island at the outbreak of WWII—is indeed the real deal: straight-up movie magic, with all the right parts in all the right places. It has subtle direction from Howard Hawks, razzle-dazzle performances from the leads and the supporting cast (including Hoagy Carmichael and Walter Brennan), and a fine script by co-written by William Faulkner (and based on the Hemingway story). The dialogue is savvy, precise, and laden with innuendo. (This is the movie in which 19-year-old Lauren Bacall, with a face as strange and beautiful as they come, teaches Bogie how to whistle: "Just put your lips together and blow.") To top it all off, Carmichael creates a poignant mini-movie all his own, playing the lonely piano man at the hotel where all the action goes down. With tired, sad eyes and a voice so soft you'll sometimes strain to hear him, Carmichael creates a backdrop of lyrical wit and pathos, a perfect foil for the world-weary lovers on the brink of true love. And dig the shimmy that Bacall pulls off at the end as she bats her eyes at Bogie. There's a lifetime of sex, love, joy, and children ahead of these two. You just can't fake this shit.
Get the Film Club Newsletter
Stay up to date on the best new movies with our critics' latest reviews, interviews and trailers for the films coming to a theater near you each week.