Wrong image, wrong religion, wrong city:
Meet Brother Ali, hip hop's unlikely savior
Dark Star

STORY BY PETER S. SCHOLTES
PHOTO BY NICK VLCEK FOR CITY PAGES

Dark Star
Wrong image, wrong religion, wrong city: Meet Brother Ali, hip hop's unlikely savior
Brother Ali: In Focus
A photo gallery by art director Nick Vlcek
Brother Ali live performances and Rhymesayers clips
Watch Brother Ali take on all challengers at various Scribble Jams, plus concert footage, and promo cuts
Free MP3s from Brother Ali's new album The Undisputed Truth from Rhymesayers:
Truth Is [5 MB]
Uncle Sam Goddamn [5.7 MB]
Marshall Field's advertisements featuring Brother Ali
Sean John
Nautica
denim jeans
More Brother Ali and Rhymesayers links at Complicated Fun
So I push back the passenger seat of my Camry, and he loads his 6-foot-2-inch, 250-pound frame into my car. We take Lyndale south under a clear night sky in February, toward the house of his producer, Ant (Anthony Davis).
"I do books on tape sometimes," Ali says, admitting that his vision problem makes him a slow reader. "I have A People's History of the United States by Howard Zinn, read by Matt Damon." He laughs. "I have The Art of War."
Sometimes the tape or the CD will be different from the original book, he says. "I have this hero thing with Bernie Mac, like he has a certain classiness about him that I want. But he has two books, and both are on CD, and both of those he just goes completely off the book, just talking."
Brother Ali has made his own name going off-book. At age 29, Ali Newman is the most acclaimed rapper from Minnesota next to his friend and label-mate Slug (Sean Daley), of Atmosphere. And he might have more commercial potential, judging by The Undisputed Truth, his third CD with local independent hip-hop powerhouse Rhymesayers, out this week. One minute, Ali's sonorous voice is a crowd-controlling force—as brash as anything since Run-DMC shouted down their own building-sized beats—and the next it's a whispery lullaby.
Yet as Ali's reading list suggests, he's different. My passenger is a blind Muslim albino who refuses to identify himself by race, though his swooping lashes and baldhead fuzz are transparent. He could be the ghost of a snowman, but he's not white.
"This is a piece of my puzzle now," he hollers on one new song. Brother Ali conjured this track, along with most of his music, in Ant's basement in south Minneapolis. Tonight, we're driving to that bat cave where rapper and producer render Ali's life in song. As Ali's midnight chauffeur, I'm hoping to find the missing piece of that puzzle.
To the future rap star, every open mic is an opportunity. Brother Ali debuted some of his earliest material at his grandmother's funeral, after most of the mourners had gone home. Having gotten his hands on the church microphone, he launched into a standup comedy routine—singing and rapping and making sound effects as relatives gathered around. He was eight years old.
To Ali, it seems as if he's always been performing. He was born Jason Newman in Madison, Wisconsin, and for a while his mom and dad moved him and his younger brother Nick to a new school or town every year, or so it seemed. They later moved to East Lansing and Portage, Michigan. But if Newman's early life in Madison overlapped with the early years of breakdancing or the interracial rap crew Fresh Force, Ali doesn't remember.
He was busy making the news himself. After his grandfather, John F. "Jack" Newman, retired from the UW news service in 1983, the veteran journalist and sportscaster took a class on clowning. The Wisconsin State Journal broke the big story. "From that grew Flash and Crash," the article reads, "a clown act he put together with his grandson, Jason Newman, 6. The Act performed at a parade in Sun Prairie this summer and in Jason's kindergarten class in Verona [a suburb of Madison] last June."
This behind-the-music story, according to Ali, is a lie. But when I tell him that his wife described the actual clown photos, Ali says that he's going to kill her.
In all seriousness, Ali says that he might have absorbed his knack for storytelling from his grandfather. To keep in touch with Jason and Nick long-distance, Jack Newman would sit down with a tape recorder and spin a tale, then mail it to them. "Sometimes it would be a cliffhanger, and we'd get a tape a week later with the finish to the story on it," says Ali.
Suspense was a constant for both grandchildren. In a way, Ali walked onstage the moment he entered any new classroom or playground: the new, fat, albino kid at school.
"I saw Ali struggle so much when he was young," says Nick Newman, who is four years Ali's junior. "With the vision, with getting treated so shitty when he was little. We went sledding one time, and these kids teamed up on him and beat up on him just because of the way he looked."

Although Masjid An-Nur welcomed everyone, the new arrival hardly went unnoticed at the mostly black mosque. "A Caucasian albino kind of stands out," says Arlene El-Amin, whose son is the congregation's imam.
Photo by Nick Vlcek for City Pages
Hip hop became Ali's way of getting respect—and an audience. He breakdanced at his first-grade talent show. He rapped Whodini's "One Love" in second grade, wearing what he hoped would look like Run-DMC gear: a powder-blue Easter suit and laceless Payless shoes.
By the time he reached ninth grade in Michigan, he'd recorded his first song on a friend's four-track: "Kickin' Poetry," which blatantly bit "Poetry" by KRS-One of Boogie Down Productions. Ali had the entire school rapping along at the talent show that year, Nick recalls. "He really gained his acceptance through his performances."
Ali got into more fights, however, and still carries a head scar from the beatdown he describes in 2003's "Win Some Lose Some." In another incident, Ali was the one instigating things, loudly telling his friends not to stand for the national anthem before a homecoming basketball game at the rich rival school. Scheduled to perform at the dance afterward, Ali never made it: He was hauled off by police for fighting, along with the rest of his crew.
"My friends were there to start shit, but I didn't see it that way," he says. "I was like, man, this is institutional racism." Everyone in the group was black except for him.
Born to parents that any census taker would describe as "white," Ali had stopped identifying as white to his friends. After catching KRS-One speak at Michigan State University (Nick had the MC sign his Bulls cap), Ali picked up The Autobiography of Malcolm X, and read it as quickly as his eyes would allow. Malcolm put to words something Ali had sensed since he was very young: that whiteness was a lie, a fiction learned by both devil and bedeviled.
"I just always viewed myself this certain way, and when I was a kid, I never understood it," he says. "My friends and their parents and their grandparents would be like, 'No, you're just black.' And I was like, 'Yeah, okay.'"
Black kids made fun of him, but not the way white kids would. "White kids would be like, 'You know your mom and dad don't want you, you freak,'" says Ali, putting on a flat Midwestern accent. "'You probably died and came back to life.' I'm talking about deep-to-the-bone 'you're not a human being'-type shit. Black kids would just be like, 'Come on, Santa Claus. Come on, Casper the Friendly Ghost. Come on, Donahue.'"
Ali told himself he was adopted, though he looked just like his redheaded brother. His refusal to call himself white would eventually cause confusion in the media. "I know way too well that I don't live a black life, and that I do benefit from white privilege," he says. "And that's why I still get freaked out by race, because of the fact that I've been so close to people who bear the brunt of it."
The lesson he learned from black friends was to look people in the eye. He began performing at conventions held by NOAH, the National Organization for Albinism and Hypopigmentation. "I used to go rap at 'em," Ali says, laughing. "But so many of the people seemed so depressed. I wanted to be like, 'Man, at least don't show people that you're sad about what you are.' I know I got that from black people."
Also in this Issue
- Slow and Steady Wins the Arms Race Low march onward with 'Drums and Guns' (Music)
- No Hurries A look at the year's most popular slow songs, so far (Music)
- Captured by Robots Generator, oscillator: Make a circuit with me! (Mash Notes)
- Caetano Veloso: cê (CD Review)
- The Klaxons: Myths of the Near Future (CD Review)
- Amy Winehouse: Back to Black (CD Review)
- Blonde Redhead: 23 (CD Review)
- Brother Ali live performances and Rhymesayers clips Watch Brother Ali take on all challengers at various Scribble Jams, plus concert footage, and promo cuts. (Galleries)
- Brother Ali: In Focus A photo gallery by art director Nick Vlcek. (Galleries)
- More articles from this issue...
About Peter S. Scholtes
From the Archive
- Nightmare on Oak Street Minnesota Film Arts downsizes its festival, prepares to sell off its screen (News - Mar 7, 2007)
- The Next Big Thing (Cover Story - Feb 28, 2007)
- If You Lived Here, You'd Be Gone By Now Katrina documentaries talk, argue, and ultimately fall silent before disaster (Film - Feb 14, 2007)
- Trampled by Turtles: Trouble (CD Review - Feb 14, 2007)
- Minnesota Jukebox Sweatin' to the local oldies—plus a newie from the Flamin' Oh's (Music - Jan 10, 2007)
- Local Music Yearbook '06 Prince went to Vegas. Smokers went to Maplewood. Tapes 'N Tapes went to the moon. And sometime after the last zombie dance party got busted, we wrote it all down for you. (Cover Story - Dec 20, 2006)
- Enter Sandman Why Neil Gaiman is about to become bigger than death (Cover Story - Nov 29, 2006)
- The Shelf Life of Socialism Inside a Leninist bookstore in West St. Paul, a familiar refrain: What is to be done? (Cover Story - Nov 29, 2006)
- More articles from the Peter S. Scholtes Archive...