U.S. Chamber of Commerce: The baddest bully in Washington

How the U.S. Chamber of Commerce became the greatest (bumbling) enemy of America

Comstock called Washington headquarters, asking that disclaimers be placed on the ads to absolve the locals of culpability. No one called back. Comstock promptly dumped her national membership.

These days, the relationship between Manchester and Washington is still toxic. "If an operative from the U.S. Chamber of Commerce comes to one of our events, I can't even sit with them, because our members would be suspicious," Comstock says. "So I don't associate with them in any way at all."

The problem, it seems, is that the boys back in D.C. still believe that businesspeople only come in a 1950s cartoon model: middle-aged conservative men with pattern baldness who storm against welfare queens and Socialists. But these days, business owners are just as likely to be yoga studio owners, software titans, or chefs with a string of locavore bistros.

The U.S. Chamber wanted taxpayers to bail out BP after the Gulf oil spill
Kris Krug
The U.S. Chamber wanted taxpayers to bail out BP after the Gulf oil spill
U.S. Chamber CEO Tom Donohue believes in small government, except when it comes to corporate welfare
U.S. Chamber CEO Tom Donohue believes in small government, except when it comes to corporate welfare

Pasadena's Little explains the diversity: "We have members who are sending rovers to Mars, and we have the guy who works on my car."

These modern members are anything but a one-note chorus. "We have 550 companies, and they probably have 550 perspectives on any given thing," adds Largo's Morrissette.

It's a diversity that's made the national Chamber's golden-parachute platform increasingly untenable. After all, when Big Oil gets welfare or Big Pharma gets special protections, the little guy gets stuck with the tab.

"I think the fundamental problem with the Chamber is that they purport to speak for the economy as a whole," says Public Citizen's Parent. "But in reality, they speak for only a very small portion of very large U.S. corporations, often to the detriment of small business."

Nowhere is this more evident than in the U.S. Chamber's secretive lobbying campaigns, where huge piles of cash turn free markets to farce.

VII. Frontman for hire. Complete anonymity, no questions asked.

And here's the beauty of it: Because the U.S. Chamber is technically nonprofit and nonpartisan, it can take a drug cartel's approach to finance, raising limitless millions without ever saying where the money comes from.

In reality, the Chamber is as nonpartisan as Fox News. More than 90 percent of its money goes to Republicans. Donohue, meanwhile, makes nearly $5 million a year while being squired around the country via private jet. For him, at least, the Chamber is plenty profitable.

But under federal law, just pretending to play it straight is good enough.

"They have unlimited resources," says the Brown campaign's Barasky. "There's no rule about how much money they can raise. You don't have to sign your name when you write them a check, so it's very easy to put out false ads all over the country."

This has led to a lucrative side business: the Chamber as frontman for hire. Companies kick money under the table, and the Chamber assumes the role of their public attack dog.

The true extent of the operation is unknown. But Prudential, Dow Chemical, Goldman Sachs, and Chevron have all been outed for signing up for the service. Their money goes to things like weakening Wall Street regulations, fighting security rules for chemical facilities, and generally sabotaging any attempt to rein in the less seemly practices of commerce.

Even when a law is passed, the Chamber's lobbying power can tie it up for years, watering it down before it takes effect.

The most bungling campaign came during debates over the Affordable Care Act. Since the 1990s, health-care premiums have averaged double-digit hikes every year, creating a diamond mine for insurers. But Obamacare requires insurers to spend at least 80 percent of those premiums on actual care — about 10 percent more than they were spending before. Anything less, and their customers get a refund.

This didn't please the insurance industry. While publicly feigning support for the Affordable Care Act, companies like Aetna, Cigna, UnitedHealth, and WellPoint secretly funneled $86 million to the U.S. Chamber, which launched a fusillade of attack ads claiming that Obamacare would give you everything but leprosy.

Even the CEO of General Electric called the Chamber's position "lunacy." Virtually the entire business world wanted something done about soaring health costs. The point wasn't whether one favored Obamacare or not. It was that the Chamber offered no meaningful alternative. It simply chose to sacrifice its members so that insurers could continue to gouge them.

But it would take even greater weirdness to drive the big boys away.

VIII. Science is a liberal plot. No, really.

Give American business credit. When global warming was finally recognized as a reality, entrepreneurs jumped in feet first, building whole new industries devoted to pure innovation, be it turning cooking grease into auto fuel or recycled plastic into synthetic wood.

"We have hundreds and hundreds of green businesses," says Terri Hiroshima of the Seattle Metropolitan Chamber of Commerce, which has also canceled its national membership. "Even organizations that have nothing to do with green often use a green lens."

But if confirmation of global warming was a triumph for free enterprise, it wasn't exactly the kind the U.S. Chamber wanted.

The national group receives big money from the coal, oil, and chemical industries. So it once again sacrificed its smaller members.

« Previous Page
Next Page »
My Voice Nation Help

This article perfectly sums up why my business avoids joining the Chamber. If you mssed the ugly ads during election season, you were sleeping. The US Chamber is definitely destroying the country with its support for candidates that would rather push dogmatic, ideologic drivel than actually run the country (if that doesn't bring a certain someone to mind, I don't know what would). The local Chambers claim they are not associated with that, but some of the local Chambers push right-wing local policies too. We are going to avoid them until they change their name to [local] Business Network or something, and show they really are not part of the Chamber's Big Business wolf in sheeps clothing.


So Pete can you write an article without being the typical left wing generalizer, let us lump all that do not believe in my views into the Sean Hannity group? You lose readers when you start an article with your political tribe.

Shaun Mason
Shaun Mason

ugh. It's like looking at the world thru a toilet paper roll tube.


@g8way This is why business people, particularly small business people have formed Independent Business Alliances.    A  number of area independent businesses formed one called the Metro Independent Business Alliance [ Metro IBA ]    and has done many very good things for the businesses,  the economy and the people of the twin cities area.      I do want to say that I am constantly horrified to see the US Chamber claim they are supporting small independent business with their extremist,  Mega Corporation positions.    If they ever support something that is good for small independent business, it is by coincidence, but they support it because it is good for  Mega Multi National Corporations.    I get regular emails from the US Chamber expressing how much they are working for Small business.   This is pure propaganda since they have no interest in small business,   just those companies that give them obscene amounts of money.       Just for clarity,  readers should know that Small Independent Business provides over 50% of all employment in America and in the last Minnesota House Research study Small Biz provided 90% of new jobs.     So the real job Creators and real job Providers are small business.   The Multi National Corps are only job creators in  third and fourth world countries and the bribed the Congress to give them a tax break for exporting our Jobs and our economy.                               John Kolstad/President, Mill City Music for  30 years.


@kmchale61  You haven't effectively refuted any of the points in the article. When you Bagger wingnuts can't attack the substance, you inevitably attack the style. Only the very stupid and gullible fall for your ploy.