Top

news

Stories

 

The Banality Bandwagon

The sad media march to the gates of the State Fair

AND SO ITbegins.

Nary a media mongrel in town can feel delight today. The State Fair cometh, and once again stories must be filed, scenes described, clever turns of phrases offered, animals and children videotaped.

Sadly, it's all been done before, far too often. All that can be said has been said. The fair as fodder has been drained to the dregs. But that won't stop the charge of the dutiful.

 Welcome to the cliché capital of news content: The Great Minnesota Clump Together. You have greasy food anecdotes? Swell. The same quips were doled out in 1967. You want to talk tradition? Get in line and bring the NoDoz. You have a neat behind-the-scenes piece on carnie life? Tear it up—Dave Moore did the story in '77 for 'CCO, and Jim Klobuchar handled it in '82 for the Star Tribune.

 Admit it, journalists are spent. This is what haunts every media outlet in town this week. You'll hold a microphone and smile that wry smile of curiosity and condescension, of phony surprise and smarmy earnestness, but deep down the specter of embarrassment and failure looms large. You'll pray for a distant road-rage crime spree or suburban garbage-house discovery, but it's dog days for local news, and the fair is where you'll be sent.

 It'll be a nightmare. Not the event itself, but the slim pickings for news features. Ultimately, it's a replica of every fair that's come before. Have fun with the portly rural folk and you'll say nothing unique. Lament how the whole event makes us look like a northern version of Iowa and you'll just repeat the thoughts of multitudes.

 But go on, camp out, deliver the panoramas and the cute kid photos, write about attendance records, or offer time capsules of yesteryear. No matter how you present it, in what way it's packaged or slanted, how carefully you aim for blessed originality, you'll inevitably join a parade of clucking clones. You'd be better off covering the new construction of a Super America

 Maybe you'll be the contrarian, say you hate it all. Well, that's now a cliché as well. You can't win. No matter which way you spin it, you'll parrot the thoughts of talking heads who've come before.

 But don't take my word for it. Dig. Find that one vendor who has something clever to offer. My money says your news piece won't match Nebraska sidewalk sale stories.

 Such is the conundrum of another late summer on St. Paul's northern border. What's left to dissect? Not enough to shake the anxiety at local assignment desks.

 The event is harmless, it's the coverage that's horrid. But do your best. Use "Pronto Pup" in another sentence and try not to wince. Who knows, maybe this year you'll get lucky and find a 92-year-old who lives for the Tilt-A-Whirl. Some wild-eyed chunk of wreckage who longs to croak on an amusement ride; not because he's suicidal but because the ride has been his lifelong love and it's a fitting way to go.

 Hear his tale: how he first fell in love with cheap thrills at the Chicago World's Fair in '33. How his lust for the escapism of controlled risk gave his existence purpose and meaning, and how that idolized exhilaration never waned, even as the decades took him far from the innocence of his youth.

 Find the angle no one's covered: the wrinkled coot yearning for a heart-stopping end on one final amusement ride. The stooped codger who, against doctor's wishes, tries to say farewell on an 80-degree vertical drop, his false teeth flying in one direction, his soul spiraling off in another.

 Now you're onto something. Now you're working with the meat of an honest-to-God story—not fair flotsam and jetsam, a bonafide page turner. Imagine the quotes:

 "I got lost on those rides from an early age, lost from my sedentary ways and my humdrum world of mindless details. I felt like a comet, a meteor, a living piece of the cosmos. Like I was born to fly, and to flail, and to scream, and to sail, and ultimately to die on that rail, having ridden all that was ever built."

Any reporters out there ready to mine a story like that? Shoot it to us, Shelby. We're hungry for something edgy, something different, something brand-new and alive, something the State Fair press hasn't offered in decades. 

 
  • Yahsure 09/25/2010 2:45:00 AM

    Because most journalists go grab a corn dog, look at the Midway, and go back to the booth until their shift is done. Nobody talks to the farmers, or they would get stories. We sleep on cots next to our animals or in the barn barracks. There is a volunteer horse patrol that clears the crowds out from our truck and trailers, because we can't see the stroller that just got pushed out in front of a 4 ton rig- or the 6 ft daddy pushing that stroller. That there is no annual human roadkill carnage at MNSF is a miracle. I tried to get a certain (pledge drive) radio station to come down to the goat barn to cover a) 5 of 7 top producing American milk goats are in MN and at MNSf or 2) goats love daquaris and we don't cut off their ears. No luck, it was the regular coverage of food that will kill you maybe in 30 years if you eat it every day until then.

  • Fair Phoebe 09/16/2010 7:37:00 AM

    Weeks late, but have fair phobias been covered, Mischke? I'm sure there are plenty of people who downright fear foodstuffs on a stick and horse poop on the streets to name a few. Personally, while I like many aspects of the fair, I loathe that rickety space needle contraption. The one and only time I went on it (circa mid 1980s) the lights cut out several times and the thing jerked. It was like the Tower of Terror at Disney mounted on an old rusty flag pole. Never again.

  • uberculture 08/28/2010 12:43:00 AM

    Wow... while I agree it might be a bit of an easy target ragging on inane fair coverage, I'm amazed how offended everyone's getting about it. Who knew this would raise such controversy? Maybe for the next column, Mischke can write about something less touchy, like smothering babies in smallpox infected blankets.

  • Mischke 08/28/2010 12:38:00 AM

    Oh, Jimmy Boy, psychologists have long known that anger comes from hurt, and clearly you have been hurt in life, my friend. I'm sorry for the pain that's come your way. I wish things were different. To correct a misperception, my damaged friend, I was never a comic genius. The term genius is tossed around a little too loosely in our world. I've never met one myself, though I've read about them. They are rare and not found generally in local media circles. I also want to point out the obvious credibility issue any man has who complains about whining while whining himself. It's unbecoming. As for good old James L., he uses humor in his writing the vast majority of the time. I never have. I'm not as interested in that. I put more of that type energy into my radio show, and even then I need a respite quite often. You're looking for pop in the produce section, I'm afraid. I'll conclude with this: I make my living spending hours each day with local media. As of 2:20 pm on this the the 27th of August I've not run across an original piece of reporting on this year's Minnesota State Fair. Nothing on radio, nothing on TV, nothing in the press. The hours that pass make my case for me far better than my column ever could. Oh, and come on, Jim, that "female dog" stuff is troll talk. You're better than a troll, and you know it. Here's hoping your anger subsides and the joy of life fills your world once again.

  • James Peterson 08/27/2010 11:33:00 PM

    How about writing a story about a onetime comic genius who turned into a bitter whiny female dog? There was a time where the talent's of Mischke and Lileks were placed right next to each other on late night radio. Lileks paled in comparison then yet today I laughed at Lileks' column which made me think of the Fair while this pile of crap makes me think of an old washed up bitter loser. An old man facing death? That's some new ground you're covering there Mischke. Why not pretend your story is true and fall deeper into your pathetic fantasy world of angst riddled self-pity?

  • kamandi 08/27/2010 1:27:00 AM

    I think someone ought to cover a duel with the State Fair robot and a talk radio host. I saw them get into a confrontation a couple of years back and I think a rubber match is in order.

  • Mischke 08/26/2010 10:22:00 PM

    My point exactly, Jerome. That was the heart of my piece. "If you can't get a story (outside cliche-ville) in a million plus people, get a job at Wal-Mart." Could't have said it better myself. Oh, one last thing, those stories done in '77 and '82 were also done last year. But you may be new in town.

  • Jerome Christenson 08/26/2010 8:02:00 PM

    If you weren't around in '77 you missed Dave Moore. If you weren't around in '82 you missed Jim Klobuchar. If you weren't around in 33ce you missed the Resurection. Get off your butt. Do the reporting. Tell the story and quit your bellyaching. If you can't find a good story in a million plus people -- get a job at Wal-mart.

  • Mischke 08/26/2010 10:38:00 AM

    The solution would be obvious to the educated. If you don't have anything new to say about the Fair, don't say anything. Just let the damn thing happen. It's a nice event. Doesn't need to be "covered."

  • Kevin Vandevoorde 08/26/2010 9:55:00 AM

    Hey, look, Comic Book Guy wrote an article! Way to go, Comic Book Guy!

  • ZZZZZZZZ 08/26/2010 7:14:00 AM

    I love folks who are content to sit back and point out the problems/failings, but can't quite rouse themselves to offer a solution -- or, in this case, "an honest to God story."

 

Most Popular Stories

Browse Voice Nation
  • Voice Places

    Voice Places

    Discover restaurants, nightlife, travel, shopping...

  • VOICE Daily Deals

    VOICE Daily Deals

    Get 50 to 90% off every day on restaurants, movies, massages...

  • Best Of

    Best Of...

    More than 10,000 of the BEST things to eat, drink, and experience

  • My Voice Nation

    My Voice Nation

    Join the Village Voice community and get exclusive deals and info

  • Happy Hour

    Happy Hour

    Your local Happy Hour guide at your fingertips

or

Log in or Sign up

Social Connect:

Use your favorite account to access My Voice Nation.


Use your My Voice Nation account to log in:





Forgot password?
or

Sign Up or Log in

Social Connect:

Sign up for My Voice Nation with your preferred network.


Sign up for a My Voice Nation account:



Privacy policy