Top

news

Stories

 

Making History

Two candidates are battling to be the first black legislator from St. Paul

MINNESOTA LEGISLATIVE DISTRICT 65A already made electoral history once. in 2002, Cy Thao became just the second Hmong state legislator in the country, hot on the heels of Mee Moua's special election to the state Senate earlier the same year. At the time, Thao's election was seen as a reflection of the new political realities in the district. He won largely by mobilizing the large Hmong population, which had up until then mostly stayed away from state politics. His victory was a validation that the Hmong had truly arrived in St. Paul, and it was hoped that he could continue the revitalization of the district that Hmong businessmen had started. Unfortunately for his supporters and the district, Thao's election didn't yield the results they were hoping for. Though he was reelected for three subsequent terms, Thao quickly developed a reputation for being inaccessible to his constituents and doing little for the district at the statehouse.

"Cy's heart wasn't really in it," says Roy Magnuson, a teacher at Como High School who chairs the teachers' PAC and is active in local DFL politics. "When you're trying to establish a career in your middle age, and at the same time you're a legislator dealing with constituent affairs, something's got to give."

Jeremiah Ellis wants to be the first African American to represent St. Paul in the statehouse
Nick Vlcek
Jeremiah Ellis wants to be the first African American to represent St. Paul in the statehouse
Rena Moran entered the race late but is gaining ground
Nick Vlcek
Rena Moran entered the race late but is gaining ground

Thao declined to comment, but several of his confidantes said that as this last legislative term wound down, he thought about running for one more cycle and then letting it go. Even in the Hmong community, there was a growing perception that his service as a representative was listless and lackluster.

"The Hmong have a saying: Your lips may be red, but you'd better be walking," says Kia Moua, a consultant on Hmong issues. "It means you can talk the talk, but you've got to actually be doing something or it doesn't count for anything. Cy Thao's lips were red, but no one really thought he was walking."

THROUGHOUT THE HISTORY of Minnesota, St. Paul has never sent a black legislator to the statehouse. That's all but certain to change this year. In the overwhelmingly Democratic 65A, both candidates vying for the DFL nomination are African American. In a district with one of the state's highest black populations, and which encompasses the remains of the historic Rondo neighborhood, many see the prospect of a black legislator as long overdue.

But the coming election is more than just a racial milestone. It's also a bare-knuckle fight between two candidates with radically different backgrounds and philosophies. The stakes are high: unemployment, poverty, and a full-blown housing crisis have already rocked the district, and many worry that the coming of the Central Corridor light rail project could add to residents' burden.

Campaigning in this district isn't easy—winning requires building a coalition of black, white, and Hmong. So with just weeks to go before the August 10 primary, both candidates are in a full sprint, working phones late into the night and criss-crossing the neighborhood knocking on doors.

State legislative district 65A lies square at the center of St. Paul. The statehouse is just blocks from its eastern edge, its shining white dome looming over the battered storefronts of University Avenue, the district's main corridor. North of University, the district extends through the modest single-family homes of Frogtown to Front and Maryland Avenues. In the northern neighborhoods of the district, like South Como and the North End, more of the yards feature Madonna statues, and many of the residents are descended from an earlier wave of European immigration. To the west, Lexington Parkway separates 65A from Hamline Midway. South of University, the howling traffic of Interstate 94 slices through the middle of the district. On the far side, 65A extends down past Selby Avenue to West Laurel, the heart of old Rondo and what is now referred to as the Summit-University neighborhood.

All told, 65A counts about 36,000 people and is one of the most diverse districts in the whole state. About a third of the residents are white, many of them young and drawn to the neighborhood by its affordable homes.

Another quarter of the residents are Asian—mainly Hmong and Vietnamese, who moved into the neighborhood in the 1980s. More recently, Latin American and African immigrants have begun to put down roots.

The district is also one of the state's poorest, and the recession has hit it particularly hard. University Avenue is littered with vacant spaces, and among the well-tended lawns and daylilies of the residential neighborhoods are some of the highest concentrations of foreclosed and vacant homes in the Twin Cities.

"This neighborhood is really hurting," said Patty Lammers, who manages home loans at the Greater Frogtown Community Development Corporation. "People here are having a hard time, and we need some strong leadership to help turn things around."

WHERE MANY SAW despair, Jeremiah Ellis saw an opportunity. The St. Paul school official had spent the past seven years building the kind of connections among local Democrats and the district's black establishment that would position him well to challenge Thao for the 65A seat.

Ellis looks much younger than his 29 years. Even with his trim goatee and stylish eyeglasses, he could easily pass for 19. He favors dark jeans and button-downs, and exudes a bouncy, agreeable energy that his supporters find infectious and his detractors regard as gratingly naive.

1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | Next Page >>
 
  • Erin 08/06/2010 7:45:00 AM

    I was really impressed with Rena and think she has a bright career in politics, but going against the DFL endorsement in such a highly DFL district is simply not a strategic move. If you are interested in a self-starter, Bo, you should appreciate that Jeremiah Ellis saw that Mr. Thao was not serving the district well and decided to challenge him. I have a lot of respect for that decision. Rena waited, and in all honesty probably wouldn't be running now if Mr. Thao had not dropped out. As much talent as I think Rena has as a community organizer, that's simply not the kind of leadership, quite frankly, I want to see in the Legislature. I also think that Take Action's endorsement in this race is an embarrassment. TAM prides itself on strategic grassroots organizing, making a tremendous difference in races with relatively few resources. In a strongly contested gubernatorial contest, and where DFLers will probably lose a fair number of seats in the Legislature, THIS is where TAM decides to prioritize its precious resources?? Really??? If I was any of the organizational members who fund TAM's electoral work, I would have a serious conversation with the organization's executives about the matter of TAM blowing their membership contributions on a race that will have very little positive impact on their statewide progressive agenda, but takes resources away from races that could actually make a difference (like the governors' race, or contested legislative races.) The St. Paul Teachers are free to back the candidates they like, and I have nothing but respect for Mr. Magnuson, but in the age of legal corporate contributions in elections, why on earth would TAM focus its resources on a race between two DFLers who are running on personality because they're ideologically so similar??

  • Lynn 07/30/2010 8:08:00 AM

    If by overlords you mean the people in the district who came out to precinct caucuses and went to the endorsing convention, then you have a point. Most people forget that party endorsements are made by district residents (i.e. your neighbors) who are in the party (or, at least in the DFL,say that they support the DFL platform), bother to show up to caucus, are selected by other neighbors to represent them at the district convention (or if there isn't a good caucus turn out, everyone from the precinct caucus is a delegate to the convention). Endorsements, especially for the district races, aren't made by party bigwigs, but by neighbors in neighborhoods. For the most part, to have a say all you have to do is show up. You don't even have to attend the caucus...most years attendence is such that if you let your precinct captain know you are interested in being a delegate to the senate district convention, you will be selected. So all you have to do is show up for the district convention. In Minnesota, it is extremely easy to have a say in who is selected at the district level. All you have to do is show up. Rena did lose caucus votes by saying she would not abide by the endorsement...she basically asked people for their support, while at the same time telling them their support was meaningless to her. Any individual's vote may be meaningless to most politicians, but saying so is one way to put off potential supporters.

  • Bo Darville 07/29/2010 6:47:00 PM

    Overstatment of the century: "It's also a bare-knuckle fight between two candidates with radically different backgrounds and philosophies." Radically different philosiphies? That's like saying RC is radically different than Pepsi. These two will vote the exactly same on every bill. The only difference is one was hand picked by our overlords and the other is a self starter.

 

Most Popular Stories

Browse Voice Nation
  • Voice Places

    Voice Places

    Discover restaurants, nightlife, travel, shopping...

  • VOICE Daily Deals

    VOICE Daily Deals

    Get 50 to 90% off every day on restaurants, movies, massages...

  • Best Of

    Best Of...

    More than 10,000 of the BEST things to eat, drink, and experience

  • My Voice Nation

    My Voice Nation

    Join the Village Voice community and get exclusive deals and info

  • Happy Hour

    Happy Hour

    Your local Happy Hour guide at your fingertips

or

Log in or Sign up

Social Connect:

Use your favorite account to access My Voice Nation.


Use your My Voice Nation account to log in:





Forgot password?
or

Sign Up or Log in

Social Connect:

Sign up for My Voice Nation with your preferred network.


Sign up for a My Voice Nation account:



Privacy policy