Top

news

Stories

 

Arizona and America Join Joe Arpaio

Are your papers in order?

Editor's note: Following publication of this article, U.S. District Judge Susan R. Bolton enjoined the state of Arizona from enacting key provisions of state Senate Bill 1070. Though the law’s most dangerous sections were put on pause, pending the outcome of litigation, the remainder of the law goes into effect, as scheduled, Thursday, July 29. See the full story on Bolton’s ruling, and read her entire decision, here.

Illustration by Tim Gabor
Governor Jan Brewer signing Senate Bill 1070
Photo by Stephen Lemons
Governor Jan Brewer signing Senate Bill 1070


WE IN THE Grand Canyon state salute, by statute, the howler monkeys in jingo trees.

Unable to regulate our border, unwilling to create a reasonable path to citizenship for the immigrants who labor in our place, Arizona law enforcement officially now undertakes to rid us of Mexicans.

Because of infamous Arizona Senate Bill 1070, which is scheduled to take effect on Thursday, July 29, the pretext of traffic stops will now initiate a search for residency papers, a practice at once abhorrent and also under consideration by as many as 20 other states.

The national terror of reconquista will now flood the streets and courts of Arizona.

The ACLU and the United States Justice Department are seeking an injunction to put SB 1070 on hold until the seven lawsuits pending can be addressed.

While lawyers cosseted in leathered briefs discuss the depth of the anti-Mexican deluge, the boots on the ground of this immigrant monsoon wear badges and guns.

If police officers were supermen, there would still be the matter of kryptonite; lawmen, however, like the rest of us, are human: The alarm doesn't go off, but the spouse does; calls get dropped, coffee gets spilled. And, every so often, officers' problems are the stuff of television drama.

Now, like Noah with his ark, the police will sort the brown in the automobile: "You two remain; you two go to Nogales."

Daniel Magos, once an immigrant, now a United States citizen, is one man who understands the divide in a cop's life.

Once, when one of Sheriff Joe Arpaio's men had a flat tire, Daniel stopped to help.

On another occasion, a deputy was adrift in a conversation with a Spanish-speaking immigrant in south Phoenix. The officer had trouble understanding or being understood. Daniel stepped forward and translated for Arpaio's man.

Nor has Magos hesitated in the face of danger.

In 2000, he saw a group of men attacking what he believed was a mojado, a wetback. Magos summoned a deputy. The lawman grabbed one of the belligerents, and as his compadres attempted to flee in a car, they tried to run over the deputy. The officer gave his prisoner to Daniel.

"You hold him for me," Magos recalled the deputy telling him.

The deputy then gave chase in his vehicle, and the pursuit ended only when those fleeing crashed their car. In the ensuing chaos, Daniel was left to his own devices. "I called the sheriff's department and asked: 'What will I do?'"

What Daniel Magos would do today, 10 years later, is walk away.

What changed?

Only this: Daniel and his wife, Eva, were recent victims of racial profiling.

Daniel and Eva were, if you will, ahead of their time, ahead of SB 1070. And herein lies a small story about what happens when we hunt Mexicans and Mexican Americans and Central Americans in our national hysteria over the brown-skinned people among us.

We hear so often that Senate Bill 1070, which demands that police — in the course of their enforcement responsibilities — question people about their citizenship, will frighten Latinos away from speaking up in domestic-abuse calls or in drug investigations or in gang probes.

Critics of SB 1070 characterize the victims of this racial profiling bill as a population caught up in some low-rent episode of Law & Order.

The caution that SB 1070 will make witnesses silent is true, as far as it goes.

But SB 1070 has a more insidious side.

The victims of racial profiling sacrificed to the nativist fears that spawned SB 1070 are just as likely to be upstanding American citizens, even Good Samaritans like Daniel Magos .

Keep this in mind as America rushes to inquire: Are your papers in order?


Born in 1945, Daniel Magos is soft-spoken, reserved, firm. Despite the run-in with a sheriff's deputy he and his wife suffered, his manner is dignified, not put-upon. He presents the sort of serenity you see upon the faces of victims portrayed on holy cards. Not to suggest Daniel is a saint — he's simply a good man and a better neighbor.

He met Eva in 1965, as a 20-year-old, at the American Legion, Post 41, in Phoenix. "I was sitting at a table by myself when she and another lady came over and asked if they could sit down. It was her friend's idea."

When he met Eva's family, he had one vivid impression: "Her father was quite strict . . . If you went out to dinner, you had to be back by 8 p.m."

Dances offered a little more leeway on time, so Eva and Daniel would visit the Calderone Ballroom on 16th Street and Buckeye Road. "Actually we went next door, to Nano's. The music and the people were different. There was a higher social status at Nano's."

1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | Next Page >>
 
  • Geezle 08/03/2010 1:29:00 AM

    This is so dishonest: "Are your papers in order." There are no papers in question, simply a green card. How do you figure that the USA has no right to control who comes in? How do you figure that we must put up with invasion? There is no race question involved except in perverse minds. If you are going to argue this issue, at least be honest.

  • Matt K. 07/30/2010 6:04:00 AM

    It's horrible to watch and feel helpless as our country, our communities turn hateful in this way and it's worse to watch the pain inflicted on others, but when making the case, as the author so eloquently does in this story, we still need to treat everyone with dignity and respect. The supporters of SB1070 are not "hillbillies" nor are they missing teeth (and even if they were, it would not be a reason to denigrate them). As we make the case for respect and equal rights for all, we must not allow ourselves to fall to the level of those who would take away rights and respect from others. The supporters of these policies, including "aREALamerican" are people, too, and they deserve our respect and decency. If they support 1070, they are badly mistaken and we should engage in the conversation with them as best we can, but we should never treat them with disrespect or hate. aREALamerican, I hope that you will take a second look at the facts and arguments presented in this article. First of all, one of the major points was that the people being hurt by these government policies and actions by government officials are American citizens. It should be common ground in this discussion that we can all agree that American citizens should not have their rights violated. Secondly, to say that "we have laws in this country" is beside the point. We all understand what the laws say. The question is whether the laws are good, right, or just. Just because something is the law does not make it right - we don't need to look too far back at our own history to find plenty of examples of laws that were just plain wrong. Finally, to the question of the immigration itself - I understand that you may disagree, but in my opinion the U.S. should greatly increase the number of legal immigrants it allows in regularly. This is not the place to lay out a full argument, but I'll say three quick things in support of this opinion. 1) The U.S. has contributed to in the past and continues to add to the hardships in Mexico (and also other Latin American countries) through trade policy (in particular, NAFTA), our demand for the drugs grown there and illegally sold here, and the supply of weapons that are easily available here and that are used in the drug wars there. 2) The continued influx of immigrants is good for the U.S. in the long-run because many immigrants take labor-intensive jobs that, in the long-run, would not be filled by native-born Americans (and would instead be outsourced to other countries) and because immigrants tend to lower the average age of the population, which will help when our Baby Boomer generation retires and begins to draw on social security. 3) The U.S. government has little claim to a moral right to enforce laws on people who have had no choice in those laws and over land that even the briefest look at history would reveal was not taken over by the U.S. in a morally upstanding way. All that being said I understand that there will and should be continued debate about the issue of immigration, especially during times of economic suffering, but I hope that it can be done in a civilized, respectful manner.

  • aREALamerican 07/29/2010 3:10:00 AM

    so all mexicans have a god-given right to one day cross our border illegally and bed down here, use our limited resources and not be required any immunizations. anyone who disagrees is a racist, stop the hate! obama dont deport my mama!! this shit is a god damn joke, we have laws in this country, and if obama is going to sit back and let the states decide, then the states WILL decide to protect themselves. illegal immigrants have absolutely zero right to protest our laws, because they are not real american citizens, they came in through the back door with the lights off, and now they want to call US racists for not supporting their law breaking? FUCK THAT

 

Most Popular Stories

Browse Voice Nation
  • Voice Places

    Voice Places

    Discover restaurants, nightlife, travel, shopping...

  • VOICE Daily Deals

    VOICE Daily Deals

    Get 50 to 90% off every day on restaurants, movies, massages...

  • Best Of

    Best Of...

    More than 10,000 of the BEST things to eat, drink, and experience

  • My Voice Nation

    My Voice Nation

    Join the Village Voice community and get exclusive deals and info

  • Happy Hour

    Happy Hour

    Your local Happy Hour guide at your fingertips

or

Log in or Sign up

Social Connect:

Use your favorite account to access My Voice Nation.


Use your My Voice Nation account to log in:





Forgot password?
or

Sign Up or Log in

Social Connect:

Sign up for My Voice Nation with your preferred network.


Sign up for a My Voice Nation account:



Privacy policy