Top

news

Stories

 

Readers respond to "Lisa Knows Best"

I hope that the serious folks who keep the lights on in our Central Business District will realize that they have created an impossible situation. No wonder developers are likely to be packing their financial bags. When a person in public office loses respect for due process, the rule of law becomes the law of the jungle, and the most ruthless predator reigns supreme. That seems to have happened in Ward Seven, and I expect the damage to our municipal good name will grow exponentially until either the electorate wises up or more stern measures are undertaken to curb the feral presence in the heart of our city.

Fredric Markus
Minneapolis

I am not a regular reader of City Pages, but my perception is certainly that you have a left-of-center political bent and so do most of your readers. I was surprised to see so much time spent on Kandiyohi in an article on Councilmember Lisa Goodman. I was even more surprised to read what seemed to be implied criticism of our efforts to develop renewable energy, create a LGBT community center, and provide housing for people living with HIV/AIDS. Let me see if I have this straight, pun intended: City Pages is critical of Kandiyohi for using its skills, experience, and influence with local policy makers to advance the causes of renewable energy and LGBT issues. Given your readers' interests, it certainly seems as if there are other targets that you could go after.

Kim Havey
Minneapolis

I'm not sure why an article about Councilmember Lisa Goodman used so much paper and ink to talk about me or Kandiyohi. In addition, there are several significant errors in your recent article that need to be corrected. I was a University of Minnesota graduate student working as a summer intern in Council Member Goodman's office on greening and storm water projects, not her "aide" as the article states. Kandiyohi Development Partners, the firm where I am currently a principal, is and always has been a for-profit limited liability corporation, not a nonprofit as was reported in the article.

Craig Wilson
Minneapolis

I am reluctant to feed the beast of City Pages' scurrilous and error-prone journalism by responding to the recent article on Councilmember Lisa Goodman. However, your tortured attempt at guilt by association is full of such complete inaccuracies that it demands a response.

First, the Green Institute's bylaws require a two-thirds vote of the board to fire the executive director, and no such vote was taken in my case. After several months of conflict with some board members over the direction of the organization, I agreed to resign—four days after a meeting with the board chair. I received a severance package equal to five months of salary and my health insurance premiums for one year.

Second, no Green Institute funds were ever used for my travel expenses, either domestic or foreign; in most cases, I paid for travel costs out of my own pocket. Particularly in the case of India, where I made two one-week trips in 2001 and 2003 to work on the Godrej Green Business Centre project in Hyderabad, my expenses were paid for by a Washington, D.C.-based consultant who had a contract through the U.S. Agency for International Development (USAID).

Finally, when I left the Green Institute in early 2005, all of its mortgage and tax payments had been made on time and we had eight consecutive years of clean financial audits from an independent auditing firm. And in my nine years with the Green Institute, I had been twice elected by my peers to serve as treasurer of other major nonprofit organizations. After nearly five years, when will Corey Brinkema and the members of the Green Institute board who continued to serve after I left stop blaming me and take responsibility for running the organization into the ground?

Michael Krause
Minneapolis

As a key player and very visible presence in the neighborhood opposition that toppled Wayzata developer Brad Hoyt's massive glass tower proposed for Loring Hill (Parc Centrale), I would have expected to be interviewed for the lengthy article written by Erin Carlyle regarding Minneapolis City Councilmember Lisa Goodman, her representation of Ward Seven, and her involvement with Hoyt's ill-fated project. But then again, my story would not have jibed with the clear bias of the writer's piece.

Though I spent countless hours phoning neighbors, knocking on doors, and canvassing the Loring Park neighborhood to rally opposition to Hoyt's project, I never received nor witnessed any help organizing the neighborhood from Lisa Goodman, as the article alleges. As a representative of my neighborhood at a City Council committee hearing on Hoyt's proposal, I witnessed firsthand criticism of my council member from the Wayzata developer that would foreshadow his lawsuit. He accused Lisa Goodman of listening to the public rather than doing what he, of course, thought was best for the city—to allow him to build his 21-story glass tower (he did not mention the approximately $23 million in profit he expected to reap from the building at the time). It struck my neighbors and I back then (as it does now) as the most ridiculous of arguments, and Goodman responded in kind—of course she listens to her constituents.

I agree with Erin Carlyle: "Lisa Knows Best," because her decisions are based on the will of the people she represents.

Michael Marn
Minneapolis

 
  • Scott Thompson 11/05/2009 10:24:00 PM

    The story of Lisa Goodman is quite disturbing - I appreciate the great information and research that City Pages has done for this piece. I don't believe for a second that Lisa Goodman respresents the will of the people - she does what is best for her and her friends. she may be hard working but development in the city is hurt when she treats developers and many others the way she does - it is just wrong. The meter farm sits there still - a parking lot - the Brad Hoyt site sits there - a parking lot - how does that generate revenue, or tax dollars for the city??? The Park Centrale building would have been a beautiful enhancement to the Loring area - I'm glad that the article pointed out that Scott Mayer's home would have been 'impacted' by the view of this new tower - a good friend of Lisa's - go figure. She should be off the city council - she has served the city enough already - too much. More power to Brad Hoyt in pursuing this matter!!

  • Cathy Cook 10/17/2009 2:43:00 AM

    Funny thing: I've read through all of the huffing and puffing by the people whose iddle feewings were hurt by this article, and not once did I hear any of them use the word "lie" -- much less the words "you'll be hearing from my lawyer". In fact, the rhetoric used sounds like it went through a lawyer first, to eliminate words like "lying" and replace them with words like "scurrilous", in what looks to me like an effort to imply the existence of untruths without putting oneself in legal jeopardy by actually claiming them. My own take is that yeah, Amy Goodman's a ward boss on the order of Boss Tweed, but the development she helped squash was best squashed. Otherwise, it'd be yet another failed real estate project in an already glutted market. Besides, the best ward bosses had their constituents' interests at heart, and that's what Goodman seems to be.

  • Bruce Balick 10/16/2009 9:52:00 PM

    It is no less than an amazing feat of �journalism� for you to not once in your entire smear of Lisa Goodman mention the zoning of the property in question. Zoning was the central issue regarding Brad Hoyt�s Parc Centrale from the very beginning. The parcel that he was proposing to build upon was zoned by City ordinance for a maximum height of two and-one-half stories due to the city-wide zoning Shoreline Overlay ordinance that relates to all bodies of water in the city of Minneapolis, and requires special review of any proposed development exceeding this height. Brad Hoyt and his lawyer knew this when he proposed his development and when they met with the Land Use Committee of the neighborhood group, Citizens for a Loring Park Community (CLPC). He definitely knew about this zoning before he bought the land. Could it have been the smell of a lucrative lawsuit against the City that led him to purchase the property? We can never know this, just as we can�t know which of many thoughts came to Councilmember Goodman�s mind when she first learned of Mr. Hoyt�s proposed development. That as a public servant she would be inclined to uphold the recently reviewed zoning of this site should be seen as commendable. There were many public meetings, with huge crowds of neighbors attending, where this proposal was debated at length. As this development project was to be in the Loring Park neighborhood, the CLPC was required to review the concept, work with the developer, and make recommendations to the City. Reaction to Mr. Hoyt�s grandiose plans for the area referred to as Lowry Hill, which consists primarily of properties four stories or less, was prompt and vocal. After months of discussions, the neighborhood recommended a zoning variance to allow for a six-story development that had been presented by Mr. Hoyt. This development was then approved by the City�s Zoning & Planning Committee, and then by the full City Council. Mr. Hoyt chose not to build his approved project. It was also the CLPC that requested the development moratorium in this area through Councilmember Goodman�s office, due to unprecedented development pressure for large buildings in this area of historic homes and small apartment buildings. Anyone who attended these public meetings with Mr. Hoyt and his lawyer would have known instantly that the central issue of these volatile discussions was zoning. How odd that your newspaper missed this central issue in your article which was short on hard facts and long on innuendo.

 

Most Popular Stories

Browse Voice Nation
  • Voice Places

    Voice Places

    Discover restaurants, nightlife, travel, shopping...

  • VOICE Daily Deals

    VOICE Daily Deals

    Get 50 to 90% off every day on restaurants, movies, massages...

  • Best Of

    Best Of...

    More than 10,000 of the BEST things to eat, drink, and experience

  • My Voice Nation

    My Voice Nation

    Join the Village Voice community and get exclusive deals and info

  • Happy Hour

    Happy Hour

    Your local Happy Hour guide at your fingertips

or

Log in or Sign up

Social Connect:

Use your favorite account to access My Voice Nation.


Use your My Voice Nation account to log in:





Forgot password?
or

Sign Up or Log in

Social Connect:

Sign up for My Voice Nation with your preferred network.


Sign up for a My Voice Nation account:



Privacy policy