Top

news

Stories

 

Readers respond to "Unusual Suspects"

I don't see the point here. Homeless crack addicts and alcoholics with mental issues are the city's biggest crime problem? Sounds as if we have a social services problem, not a criminal problem. Was that your point?

Comment by eric

Great article, Erin! These guys are a big pain in the ass for the city and its residents. No one knows how to fix them; their problems are intractable and so is their behavior. No one knows how to get rid of them. Where would they go even if you could convince them to leave? Really, they need babysitters, but instead the police are left trying to minimize the amount of nastiness, inconvenience, and harm they do to other people who are simply trying to go about their daily lives.

Comment by Jane
from Minneapolis

Yes, I've seen a number of these clowns. Good to know the police know who they are. Maybe I will make sure I have the Mace and/or Taser ready for the Skyway Jerk-off.

Comment by Bobbi
from Minneapolis

Thanks for the article. As a downtown worker who parks in the Target "A" Ramp, I've seen plenty of these folks. Any chance the list of the whole 200 is available somewhere?

Comment by dt worker
from Minneapolis

I am a little perplexed by this article. On one hand, I could not agree more that troublesome repeat "losers" like these deserve some airtime. On the other, I'm a resident/homeowner in the Phillips neighborhood and wish that the story would have continued along the lines of the way it was introduced. It really had me going (blood boiling, the whole thing) with the tale of the woman (Metge) coming home to that horrific scene at her house. Then...what? How does this story work itself into that listing of undesirable citizens?

Comment by Mary
from Minneapolis

What about the fact that there are programs that work with people "like this"? The problems are being addressed, but there needs to be more support from the community, including the local media.

This kind of article just makes people more angry and scared of the people walking down the street next to them. It breeds negativity toward our neighbors and insensitivity toward the very real issues these people are facing: racism, discrimination, childhood abuse, mis- or undiagnosed mental illness, substance abuse, unlivable wages, ridiculously high rents, the high cost of healthcare, etc.

Comment by MarsBars
from Minneapolis

This article reads as it should. A few make it bad for the rest. Eight years working on Currie Avenue, moving drunks, addicts, and dealers along, breaking up fights, and attending to the wounded are part of the lesson. Jana Metge nows acts with the Downtown Courtwatch, which for the first time in my 15 years working for the homeless is addressing these thugs with action. We should be hard on the worst offenders—with prison time. However, Courtwatch allows us to address mental illness or chemical dependency and get lower-level offenders the help they need other than prison. Good job, Erin, and I can tell you that if this citizen sees Earl Darling again (who is far more than a nuisance—I've witnessed him commit two assaults against two women on the same day and a recent arrest for an alleged rape) I may just give him some street justice. Peace!

Comment by Dominick
from Minneapolis

And City Pages sinks further into irrelevance with this story. You are making fun of sad, mentally ill homeless people with substance abuse problems—and in such a smug way. I assume this is an extension of your high school hobby of making fun of special needs kids.

Comment by chris
from Minneapolis

This article is socially and morally irresponsible. It serves no purpose other than to perpetuate stereotypes. It offers no solutions to the problem nor does it detail the programs already working to help get people off the streets. This is pure exploitation.

Comment by Treana
from Minneapolis

Hey Treana, nice comment. Have you ever had anyone grab you in the crotch or molest you in a public place? Well, I think if you were a victim of a crime like this you would want others to know so it doesn't happen to them, since the judicial system doesn't do anything and keeps letting them out! Shame on you, Treana. Why don't you go visit them and maybe take Mr. Singletary on a date—maybe you can keep him from grabbing our crotches...let him grab yours!

Comment by Mille
from Minneapolis

 
  • 05/24/2011 5:00:00 AM

    The drug crank is a higher dosage of amphetamine that can be used in many different ways in order to reap the benefits of its high. The effects of crank can cause high blood pressure, and the constriction of blood vessels. Crank was cheap, cooked in bathtubs, and cut with ephedrine. Back then, it was known as the poor man’s cocaine. Today, crank is almost never found on the streets. Ephedrine is illegal, and the bathtub labs designed to cook up a batch are a scientific experiment of the past. Addiction to methamphetamine, however, is not. Drug treatment centers have seen methamphetamine addiction skyrocket as Crystal Meth, crank’s evil stepchild, has taken hold of many people across the nation, including many in my hometown in Nevada. Crank Addiction

  • Plugger 08/27/2009 10:49:00 AM

    I guess this is why people run to the sticks, listen to country, and never set foot in the Cities if they can help it. However you have to deal with methheads, drunks, and Big Pants-wearing Republicans out there. How about a Top Ten Local Yokels from the suburbs list next time?? And scary dude from the shelter is right: Us honkeys would never survive a day in the shelters, much less a week. It's hard enough surviving the bus ride to school. Not all our kids get handed their higher education, just so you know. Some of them have to ride thru the ghetto and back for the priviledge of a career waiting on your sorry asses when they become doctors, lawyers, and pharmacists.

  • MarsBars 08/19/2009 3:54:00 AM

    I kind of feel sorry for Erin Carlyle though. I mean, here she is, with a Masters in Journalism from Columbia and an undergrad degree from Stanford. And she ends up having to do *this* story, for this craptacular paper - for crying out loud there's a Smitten Kitten ad featuring a mermaid vibrator next to this comment form - covering these losers. Let's nominate this story for a Pulitzer. It's excellent work when you consider what other kinds of meaningful material she could have put her time and energy into (you know, the kind of journalism that inspires and creates social change and all that kind of crap). Those thousands of dollars in loans (unless mummy and daddy paid for her schooling...), she's gotta get work where she can, am I right? You're a martyr, Erin Carlyle. That's what you are.

  • Dennis Grace 08/07/2009 6:01:00 PM

    After reading your "story" on Unusual Suspects I was wondering just what you have coming down the pipes to titillate us next. The ten poorest families and what they have to do to survive? Maybe something on the order of the pleasures of sleeping outside in the winter? I can't believe anyone with an objective mind could find anything of intrinsic value to this piece of sorry drivel. I am going to place a long shot bet and guess that none of these people wake up every morning and say, "God it's good to be like this, and I sure wouldn't change a thing." Even the retarded, which I strongly suggest you may wish to check The high and mighty Erin Carlyle for, would be able to see that these people (yes Erin, they are still considered people)have issues that you couldn't even begin to conceive of. I do volunteer work for an agency that helps these "people" try to stay alive. Forget living a normal life, I'm talking surviving. I personally know two of the people featured. Did you know Larry Henley helps support his mentally challenged girlfriend, as well as some of her family? Can you even fathom what it's like to push a couple of hundred pounds of metal in a shopping cart from south Minneapolis to the north side when it's 90 degrees and humid? or ten below zero through the snow? I have known Larry for over 10 years, and woman you don't have a clue to what/who he is, and what kind of a good man he is. Is he perfect? No. And obviously, neither are you. And I will bet dollars to dogshit that you didn't even contact one of these "people" to see who they really are. You sat in some air conditioned office, gathered some facts, and produced this piece of shit reporting. Easy to pick on people who can't defend themselves, isn't it? You can use my name (please do) and I am not afraid to say Larry is my friend. I will also bet you won't have the journalistic honesty to print this. Dennis Grace. P.S. May I also suggest that you change your name from Erin to Air In (the head) Nuff said.

  • Royce Lerwick 08/06/2009 12:55:00 AM

    Identification of the problems is naturally the first step in eliminating them. Two hundred is a lot to deal with in one go however, so personally I think the City Pages list is just about the right size to get started with some of the ring leaders.

  • Jim 08/05/2009 9:27:00 PM

    I was morbidly astounded at the publication of this article. What the hell was the purpose of turning homeless/mentally ill individuals into an entertainment commodity for hip City Pages readers?? If this article does anything besides ignore the severity of social ills in urban areas, then it at least speaks to the lack of resources, education, and understanding our city has in dealing with the sick and substance addiction community. "We're talking about people who just make things miserable," says Minneapolis Police Sgt. William Palmer. "It's always been said that there's a very small number of people within any community that cause most of your headaches." Exactly, people who are annoying, who panhandle, who steal Listerine to get fucked up, women who beg for money for crack... to assume that there won't be individuals living in a community who need help or are mentally unstable is a pretty ignorant perspective. Only until these individuals make their way from low income housing projects or shelters to downtown where your privileged readers are forced to deal with them, is it a problem. If this is what Minneapolis residents feel to be the biggest societal problem- panhandlers in downtown... ?? Jeeeezus Christo, this is appalling... "Among the crackheads and petty thieves, Henley has distinguished himself with his particular obsession: scrap metal." Particular obsession?!?!?!?! Try source of income! Omigod this is absurd.. And Jackson: "He's infatuated with Michael Jackson," Officer Queen says. "He believes they're related because of their last names." Does making fun of people with clear mental illness really how you need to get response from your readers?? And Darling: "Most of his offenses are laughably petty. Darling has ordered drinks and then not paid for them. He stole a $2.20 box of pasta from Macy's, a $5.79 pack of Newport cigarettes, and $2.20 AA batteries from Kmart. He urinates in public. He walks around drunk and high. In March, he allegedly beat up an 18-year-old security guard who woke him from a nap in the skyway. People like Darling "don't get jobs," Palmer says. "They're criminals. They don't commit one crime a week�this is what they do full-time." You have got to be kidding me. WHAT POINT DOES THIS PROVE. This IS THE MOST IRREVERENT, hedonistic article for the enjoyment of the upper class. Bravo to the readers with steady incomes who have to criticize those that don't and have gone mentally ill from living in such formidable living conditions. I hate to sound like Queen Bee Social Worker, but wouldn't it be great, satisfying, even entertaining to open the City Pages and see the mugshot of maybe your Uncle or even mother, "just another Franlkin Avenue Crackhead" as the laughing stock of your primarily young, white, post-graduate audience. Super cool City Pages, you guys deserve a pat on the back for this one!

  • Maija Liisa Varda 08/05/2009 6:46:00 AM

    I found it extremely entertaining to read about some random ten people stealing mouthwash, smoking crack, and drinking until they pass out. I wish all these poor and disadvantaged people would go away too! Mentally unstable people�what a drag! I�m so glad someone finally pointed out how homeless addicts just RUIN everyone else�s lives! This is really an amazing piece of journalism, one that does not smack of bigotry, social ignorance, and procrastination on an article deadline at all. Bravo.

  • Andrew Collins 08/05/2009 1:30:00 AM

    �The business of a newspaper is to afflict the comfortable.� So goes the old saw. Yet, in describing the recent cover story �Unusual Suspects,� we would do better to say: �The business of the City Pages is to further afflict the already-quite-afflicted.� For this piece combines the inherent idiocy of lists, with the worst conservative fallacies about crime, to achieve ends both troublesome and offensive. It is structured around an attempted individuation of notorious criminals, wherein each is represented by a humiliating mug shot, a ridiculous�occasionally racist�nickname, and a short blurb fetishizing his singular quirks. All in line with the �Dirty Harry� etiology of crime as the product of unsponsored monsters, each an island unto himself. Why is it, then, that in reading the histories of these allegedly �unusual� troublemakers, one invariably finds the same story�one of extreme poverty, mental illness, homelessness, and addiction? These are systemic problems! Such problems did not originate with ten human beings, the responsibility for which they do not bear, the cessation of which will not occur when they have fallen away. Even if, in the spirit of this article, we were to promptly commence in stoning these pitiable persons in the city square, thus saving Joe Taxpayer a dime, then surely others would arise in their stead, to offend the citizenry once more with their chronic troubles. �What�s wrong with the system?� asks Sgt. Reinhardt, and Erin Carlyle�s reporting does nothing to illuminate this question. If individualized profiles are to be insisted on, then bring these criminals center, I say, let them stand forth on the public stage so as to articulate their own histories and troubles, their hopes and fears, etc. It is never a good sign when the only source on a piece of investigative reporting is the MPD. In the absence of nuanced portraiture, or of any real social analysis, we are left with only a set of mute caricatures�caricatures that are not only mean-spirited, but utterly futile as well.

 

Most Popular Stories

Browse Voice Nation
  • Voice Places

    Voice Places

    Discover restaurants, nightlife, travel, shopping...

  • VOICE Daily Deals

    VOICE Daily Deals

    Get 50 to 90% off every day on restaurants, movies, massages...

  • Best Of

    Best Of...

    More than 10,000 of the BEST things to eat, drink, and experience

  • My Voice Nation

    My Voice Nation

    Join the Village Voice community and get exclusive deals and info

  • Happy Hour

    Happy Hour

    Your local Happy Hour guide at your fingertips

or

Log in or Sign up

Social Connect:

Use your favorite account to access My Voice Nation.


Use your My Voice Nation account to log in:





Forgot password?
or

Sign Up or Log in

Social Connect:

Sign up for My Voice Nation with your preferred network.


Sign up for a My Voice Nation account:



Privacy policy