Top

news

Stories

 

Readers respond to RNC Protest Coverage

Throw the bums out

I am sick and tired of reading about how many journalists were arrested during the RNC convention ("Arrested Development," 9/10/08). Whether it was one or a thousand, it is an attack on the First Amendment. We don't need to know whether they were Fox News automata or Al Jazeera brown people—what we need to know is how to put a stop to it! Other than donating to the National Lawyers Guild, the American Civil Liberties Union, and voting against Mayor Coleman and Judge Mark Wernick (who refused to grant an emergency motion asking for "injunctive relief to prevent police from seizing video equipment and cellular phones used to document their conduct"), what else can we do?

Alfredo Lorente Minneapolis

How to fight back

I found the article "Dozens of journalists arrested at RNC" to be very eye-opening. I was also arrested on Thursday, 9/4, but at 12th and Cedar. My friends and family didn't believe that I was just being a "peaceful protester" and think that I must have done something to deserve being arrested. After passing around your article, people started believing that I was completely innocent. The only reason I was taken into custody was because there were way too many "frat boy (or girl) rejects" that wanted to take out their aggression on peaceful, law-abiding individuals. I found a group that has put together a court solidarity plan trying to help those who were arrested. Since going to two of their meetings I feel much better about what I've been going through after being arrested. I was hoping that their website could be printed in your paper, as I'm assuming there are quite a few arrestees out there who read City Pages. Even if not interested in court solidarity, it's a place to connect with others and talk about what happened that godawful week. Coldsnap Legal Collective can be reached at: http://coldsnaplegal.wordpress.com.

Angie Via internet

Bait and switch journalism

"DID YOU HEAR THE REPUBLICANS ARE BUILDING A SMOKING SECTION AT THE XCEL CENTER?" Well, no. Not until you said so ("Smoke-Filled Room," 8/27/08), and then—10 paragraphs later—explained that there is no smoking room. So your goal was to...what? Make the GOP look bad by creating and dispelling a rumor in a single article? As if there aren't enough true stories for that. I suggest Bradley Campbell give up journalism and look for a job in the tabloid industry, where they let you waste all the paper you want.

Thirty Harry Minneapolis

No more Tom Tomorrows

I don't know what City Pages pays for Tom Tomorrow's "comic" This Modern World, I imagine not very much, but it is not worth the price, however low. Tom Tomorrow consistently proves the stereotype within the comics world that (with few exceptions like Pat Oliphant) editorial cartooning is the least creative form of comics art and attracts its lowest and least intelligent practitioners. I think that anyone smart enough to read who cares about politics already knows what the DNC talking points of last week were without having a poorly drawn, two-dimensional penguin regurgitate them. Tom Tomorrow's comic is consistently witless, hectoring, and insulting in tone to anyone who doesn't march in rigid lockstep with mainstream "good ol' boy" Democratic leftism.

Sandez Rey Via email

No vaccine for autism ignorance

Letter writer Heather O'Brien would do well to actually do some research herself before repeating the preposterous claim that childhood vaccinations cause autism or slandering a nonprofit public health group (Letters to the Editor, 9/10/08 in response to Bradley Campbell's article). This "vaccines cause autism" claim has been repeatedly debunked over the last decade, and despite the fact that vaccination uptake rates have actually dropped among some groups due to this scaremongering, autism diagnosis rates are not going down at all.

O'Brien identifies "mercury-containing" flu vaccines as the cause of autism. Presumably she is referring to thimerosal, an innocuous preservative that has been identified as a cause of autism by the infectious-disease proponents since the mid-'90s. And yet autism rates have continued to increase since 2001, when thimerosal was removed from all routine childhood vaccinations to assuage the fears of parents. So now she blames a flu vaccine that only 30 percent of pregnant women receive? Her fellow travelers have been changing their tune every time a pet theory is debunked. First it was the MMR vaccine. Then Japan stopped using that vaccine entirely, and autism rates in that country continued to increase. Then the cause was supposedly thimerosal, until it was removed from childhood vaccinations and autism rates continued to increase. Now the infectious-disease proponents are either identifying the vaccine schedule or the aluminum in vaccines as a cause. I imagine once those have also been shown to be ludicrous they will move on to something else.

Childhood vaccinations were one of the most important advances in public health in the last century. Anyone who would like a glimpse into the world before routine vaccinations should ask an older relative or friend about avoiding the public pool during polio outbreaks, or visit an old cemetery and count the infant headstones. The only thing confusing about vaccines is why someone would want to return to that level of infant and child mortality.

Natalie Martin Minneapolis

 
  • buhlCHEER 10/14/2008 10:57:00 PM

    Yeah!

  • A Concerned Mother 09/25/2008 10:50:00 AM

    Would the real Natalie Martin please stand up?....Lisa Randall

  • moboface 09/25/2008 9:35:00 AM

    When are people like Natalie Martin going to wake up and realize they're part of the problem. There's an epidemic of autim, and everyone is crying 'not it'. Help our children already!

  • Heather O'Brien 09/25/2008 7:30:00 AM

    Natalie Martin�s Red Herring letter �No vaccine for autism ignorance� does nothing to address the valid concerns regarding vaccines and autism. To call those who question vaccine safety �infectious-disease proponents� is absurd. The parents of vaccine injured children who are saying "Too Many, Too Soon, Too Toxic", are very educated in vaccine and autism research. We read articles from Pub Med, meet with legislators, attend cutting-edge medical conferences, and attend government meetings like the National Vaccine Advisory Committee meeting where Voices for Vaccines the "nonprofit public health group" called for the end of autism related vaccine safety research. "Ms. Martin", stop the name calling and the fearmonering. Vaccination rates are at historic highs and so are chronic childhood illnesses like autism. Our children need help. They need safer vaccines.

  • nhokkanen 09/24/2008 7:42:00 PM

    Let's see who hasn't done their research. Today in Washington, DC vaccines & autism will be discussed at a 2 pm Capitol briefing by Rep. Carolyn Maloney. So much for that claim being "preposterous"; more than 100 members of Congress and Senate are planning to attend, or sending a representative. Also, the Federal Omnibus Autism Proceedings that began in 2002 (part of the "vaccine court") are still being heard , with verdicts expected in 2009. http://www.uscfc.uscourts.gov/omnibus-autism-proceeding Mercury and autism will be discussed at the 25th annual International Neurotoxicology Conference in New York Oct. 12-14. The advocacy group Autism Speaks is awarding several grants to study Thimerosal and autism. Go ask the vaccine manufacturers -- Thimerosal was never removed from childhood vaccines; it's chelated postproduction. But it's not in the attenuated MMR vaccine. Still, children in Minnesota have biopsies showing vaccine-strain measles in lesions lining their gastrointestinal mucosa. Imagine their misery. For further elucidation, read reports to the Vaccine Adverse Events Reporting System. Then ask how much effort and money the CDC spends on vaccine injury prevention. Good luck finding any. http://vaers.hhs.gov/ Read these CBS News quotes from Dr. Bernadine Healy, medical editor at U.S. News & World Report, former director of NIH, former head of American Red Cross, and an advisor to George W. Bush: "I think the government or certain public health officials within the government have been too quick to dismiss the concerns of these families without studying the population that got sick." "I think public health officials have been too quick to dismiss the hypothesis (vaccines can trigger autism) as irrational without sufficient studies of causation." http://www.ageofautism.com/2008/09/olmsted-of-auti.html What that refers to is the statistical skewing described in David Kirby's 2005 book Evidence of Harm. But people who skim for convenient conclusions won't learn that. Bottom line: Priorizing safe vaccines is not analogous with avoiding them. People who scaremonger with tales of outbreaks from long ago are missing the point. This is not an either/or argument, and such willful mislabeling is irresponsible and counterproductive. Vaccine policymakers can work to simultaneously suppress communicable disease and reduce vaccine injury. But it means shifting priorities, backtracking, reworking formulas. And shifting the definition of "safe" back to Webster's, instead of the CDC's utilitarian mantra that the benefits outweigh the risks. No child deserves to be written off as collateral damage in the war on disease. And a problem of this magnitude will never be whisked under the table by online posturing and denials.

  • david ayoub 09/24/2008 5:52:00 AM

    Who is ignorant about vaccines, autism and thimerosal? Thimerosal is not considered innocuous according to the manufacturers own statement. It is absurd to think mercury is safe in any form or dose. What is absurd is the level of protection thimerosal provides in sterilizing multi-dose vials. It was known since the 1950's that is was a poor sterilizing agent and the 2004 Chiron flu vaccine shortage was the result of contamination in spite of its use. Thimerosal exposures have climbed again since 2004 because of substantial changes in the flu vaccine schedule.....small kids now get as much as 60% of the dose given "before removing it". Hardly a reduction. As a physician I have personally seen children regress after a flu vaccine. The junk papers debunking a link are largely funded by vaccine makers...no surprise. On the other hand nearly every study by independent researchers has shown a link to vaccines and autism...both MMR and mercury containing. Since the infant mortality rate in the US is highest among industrial nations, it is difficult to see how we can do much worse by ignoring the advice of policy makers at the CDC and FDA who are in bed with vaccine makers for profits.

  • Mr. Jones 09/24/2008 1:56:00 AM

    The writer on 9/23/08 is right, vaccines with mercury do not cause autism (a psychiatric disorder from the DSM-IV manual). There are now 11 published, peer-reviewed papers that identify the underlying medical conditions of autism as neuroinflammatory disease. One of these papers is titled, "Neuroglial Activation and Neuroinflammation in the Brains of Patients with Autism". It was done at John Hopkins University using brain tissue from deceased autistic patients. Now, does the writer want to debate whether mercury, a known neurotoxin added to childhood vaccines at levels 250 times higher than what the EPA identifies as hazardous waste, causes neuroinflammatory disease? Does the writer want to debate whether brain damaged kids behave in a way so that some psychiatrist can label them as somewhere on the autism spectrum? Also, there are still 11 licensed vaccines in the U.S. with the full amount of thimerosal (50% mercury).

 

Most Popular Stories

Browse Voice Nation
  • Voice Places

    Voice Places

    Discover restaurants, nightlife, travel, shopping...

  • VOICE Daily Deals

    VOICE Daily Deals

    Get 50 to 90% off every day on restaurants, movies, massages...

  • Best Of

    Best Of...

    More than 10,000 of the BEST things to eat, drink, and experience

  • My Voice Nation

    My Voice Nation

    Join the Village Voice community and get exclusive deals and info

  • Happy Hour

    Happy Hour

    Your local Happy Hour guide at your fingertips

or

Log in or Sign up

Social Connect:

Use your favorite account to access My Voice Nation.


Use your My Voice Nation account to log in:





Forgot password?
or

Sign Up or Log in

Social Connect:

Sign up for My Voice Nation with your preferred network.


Sign up for a My Voice Nation account:



Privacy policy