Top

news

Stories

 

Minnesota's first adoption malpractice case devastates parents

They cut her umbilical cord. Now, she's cut off from them forever.

"Don't talk to me again,"Stacy Mooney found herself saying,"until she is 100 percent sure."

David Kern
courtesy of Stacy Mooney

She was speaking to her boss at the Holiday gas station in Navarre. After trying desperately since 2002 to get pregnant, Stacy and her husband Ty had finally made the decision to adopt. Stacy was already feeling her motherly instincts welling up inside her. To even contemplate getting close and having it not work out was too much to bear.

It had taken Ty a long time to realize how much he wanted kids. He liked them, sure—he was crazy about his niece. But even after he and Stacy were married in Hawaii on September 27, 2001, Ty felt no rush to start reproducing. He was a young guy still, and his job at U.S. Airways gave him and his wife ample opportunity to travel the world.

Then Ty saw friends his age coaching their kids in youth sports and thought, look what I'm missing. Maybe that world travel they'd dreamed of could include a child. The year following their wedding, Ty and Stacy started trying to have a baby.

But it wasn't happening. They had tests done, and it still wasn't happening. So the Mooneys began talking about adopting.

The day her boss finally told Stacy that yes, his pregnant friend was sure, 100 percent sure, was September 1, 2006. Nine days later, the boss's wife came to the Mooneys' Elk River home with a twentysomething woman she introduced as Crystal Orr. Too early in her pregnancy to even be showing a baby bump, Crystal brought along the second of her three children to the Mooneys' ranch-style house.

The Mooneys made their guests dinner and gave them a tour of the house, including the nursery set up with a crib, toys, and other baby necessities. It was important to Stacy that Crystal know the child she carried would have everything a baby could want.

It was enough to convince Crystal. "I want you to have this baby," Stacy remembers Crystal saying. "This is your child. I'm just carrying her for you."

 

DANIEL L. GILES TURNS 60 this October. He'll mark his 30th year practicing law in 2009.

The bearded, mustachioed Giles is a partner in the Marshall firm Stoneberg, Giles and Stroup. The firm mainly advertises for personal injury cases, but they also handle business law, agriculture, estate planning, and real estate transactions.

It was the last of these that found Stacy Mooney's parents, Debs and Al, doing business with senior partner Paul Stoneberg. The deals had ended without a hitch.

So when Stacy told her parents that she and Ty had found a baby to adopt, they suggested she work with the law firm they'd trusted for years. The day after the Mooneys met with Orr for the first time, Debs and Al went to Stoneberg's office to ask if the firm handled family law. Yes indeed, Stoneberg told them, and introduced them to Giles.

They struck an arrangement. Giles would dispense all necessary legal advice and handle all the paperwork.

In the meantime, the Mooneys and birth mother Orr were becoming close. On September 21, 2006, the two women attended Orr's first medical appointment together, something that soon became a monthly ritual. The Mooneys offered to pay for any medical bills that insurance wouldn't cover, but Orr never asked for a dime.

Orr had her own reasons for wanting the adoption to go smoothly. She was involved in a custody case involving her eldest child. She wanted to avoid anything that would reflect poorly on her with the court.

In October, Orr and the baby's birth father ended their relationship, with the man planning to leave the state. Orr wanted to be certain he signed an adoption consent form before that happened.

Don't worry, Stacy assured her, we're on top of it.

On November 24, Stacy called Giles. They needed to get this man's consent, she told him—and don't we need an adoption agency to do some official study of our home?

No, Giles assured her. You don't need a home study for this type of adoption.

That seemed odd to Stacy, but she took him at his word.

Of the types of domestic adoption available, the route the Mooneys chose is the most modern, but also potentially the trickiest. When an expectant mother and an adoptive couple connect on their own, then go to a lawyer for a binding agreement, legal hurdles exist that other forms of adoption bypass. Called "direct placement" adoptions, these agreements have only been recognized by Minnesota's law since the early 1990s.

Before that, says adoption law expert Gary Debele, state government and adoption agencies handled virtually all the arrangements. A couple could either adopt a ward of the state—usually a child whose parents' rights had been revoked—or go through an adoption agency. The process was overseen by professionals and cloaked in secrecy. Birth parents never knew who adoptive parents were and vice versa. Social workers made decisions about where children would be placed.

But there was a backlash. Agencies realized secrecy might not be best from a child-development perspective. Demographics were also changing. With social taboos about single parenthood diminishing, more birth mothers began keeping their babies.

1 | 2 | 3 | Next Page >>
 
  • john keck 06/15/2010 7:18:00 PM

    this is rylees biological father again,someway,somehow i will be in rylees life someday.i am not trying for full custody,just visitation.ive never even met rylee,but i already love her more than anyone else could.

  • john keck 05/14/2010 11:41:00 AM

    stacy mooney is not a person that can be trusted

  • john keck 02/24/2010 2:13:00 AM

    i never would have left the state if someone hadnt told me crystal had a miscarage it wasnt till may 2007 that i found out i had a daughter.i had always wanted a daughter and stacy said that i could be in rylees life.ive never before woke up with tears pooring down my face till recently that it happend.it started out as a dream where i could see her but not reach her.all i have is a few pictures of rylee.so if anyone can help me i would sicerely appreciate it.

  • john keck 02/24/2010 2:04:00 AM

    this is rylees biological father,if anyone can give me any information on rylee please do so

  • john keck 02/24/2010 2:04:00 AM

    this is rylees biological father,if anyone can give me any information on rylee please do so

  • S. Chamberlain 12/29/2009 8:04:00 AM

    This is DISPICABLE!!! I don't see how their needs to be "another side to the story"!!! If this Crystal wanted to give the baby up for adoption why on earth would you rip her away from such an amazing couple!!! Shame on this young woman, I hope you have a hard time sleeping at night because what you did to this innocent couple should be a CRIME!!! There is nothing you could say that would justify you taking the baby away from them because their attorney was an idiot that screwed up some paperwork! You will reep what you sow, and in this case, I hope its years of agony for what you did to this couple....especially Stacy!!!

  • john keck 08/13/2009 3:45:00 AM

    this is john again,this time im writing to say that there is a lot more to this story than is said on here.i have my side and have heard of rumors that crystal started.im not going into detail on here,if anyone has any questions i would be happy to answer them.all im asking is to meet and spend time with rylee,but it seems like what i want doesnt matter and it hurts.so please,whoever knows anything,help me out.

  • john keck 08/11/2009 1:38:00 AM

    this is rylees biological father.i just wantd to say that the only reason i left the state in 07 was because 2 people told me that crystal had a miscarige.all i want is too be in her life,so if anyone can help with that than please let me know,thanks.

  • john keck 08/11/2009 1:38:00 AM

    this is rylees biological father.i just wantd to say that the only reason i left the state in 07 was because 2 people told me that crystal had a miscarige.all i want is too be in her life,so if anyone can help with that than please let me know,thanks.

  • john keck 07/24/2009 4:56:00 AM

    this is rylees father,if anyone has any info on rylees whereabouts please email me.when i signd the papers for stacy and tyrone we had a verbal agreemant that i would be included in rylees life.i had always wanted a daughter,but i have never met her and shes already 2 years old.it gets harder every day.i dont know who has her but at least give her a kiss for me,thank you.

  • J.M. 07/01/2008 7:40:00 PM

    Sad. very sad. We have lost a sibling group of three that was placed with us to be adopted. The foster mother changed her mind the day before the kids were to be ours forever. Since she was a distant relative, she got the kids. These kids lost siblings (our biological children), pets, a mom and a dad (foster mom isn't married), cousins, their new room and home, and much more. Even though there were no legal costs, we spent thousands of dollars in preparation for these children. The only thing we didn't prepare was our hearts to be broken. Everyone was told that we were their new mom and dad. The kids all called each other brothers and sisters. It was not a trial period. We loved them with all our hearts. It was such a privilege to tuck them in and say prayers with them every night. They had bonded with us and were doing so well. Maybe too well. The "professionals" kept waiting for the worst, but it never came. Except for us. The social worker didn't dare show up at our house (she had actually never been to our home nor met our bio children). Neither had the guardian ad litem. Neither of these has ever had a child or been a parent (common theme among many child social workers). She sent an "assistant" to pick up all the kid's belongings. It was very, very, sad to have to sort through closets, toy boxes, and dressers splitting up what stays and what goes. I, of course, never wrote their names on anything because we never dreamed this would happen. I asked my three year old daughter which dolls were hers and which ones were her sister's (also 3), and she said, "mommy, we share, remember?" I cried and cried. we all did. Losing a child is the hardest thing a person will ever have to go through, no matter what the circumstances. We are thankful to have our faith in God and that he will always be there. Sometimes He doesn't calm the storm, but he always calms His child. We have just recently begun to look again at adoption and are hopeful that there are more good stories than bad ones. Our prayers go out to other families who have lost children. Peace be with you.

 

Most Popular Stories

Browse Voice Nation
  • Voice Places

    Voice Places

    Discover restaurants, nightlife, travel, shopping...

  • VOICE Daily Deals

    VOICE Daily Deals

    Get 50 to 90% off every day on restaurants, movies, massages...

  • Best Of

    Best Of...

    More than 10,000 of the BEST things to eat, drink, and experience

  • My Voice Nation

    My Voice Nation

    Join the Village Voice community and get exclusive deals and info

  • Happy Hour

    Happy Hour

    Your local Happy Hour guide at your fingertips

or

Log in or Sign up

Social Connect:

Use your favorite account to access My Voice Nation.


Use your My Voice Nation account to log in:





Forgot password?
or

Sign Up or Log in

Social Connect:

Sign up for My Voice Nation with your preferred network.


Sign up for a My Voice Nation account:



Privacy policy