By Alleen Brown
By Maggie LaMaack
By CP Staff
By Jesse Marx
By Jesse Marx
By Maggie LaMaack
By Jake Rossen
Dean Zimmermann was a politician with an unhappy constituency. In fact, the problem lay with one voter in particular--his wife. He had lived in the Phillips neighborhood for some 20 years, before marrying progressive activist Jenny Heiser in 2002. He promised her then that one day soon they would buy a house together. Nevertheless, as the months and years ticked by, the City Council member balked at making a move. Meanwhile, he represented his ward from an old triplex at 25th Street and 17th Avenue South.
So, when Zimmermann announced a month ago that he would seek reelection to the Minneapolis City Council, it wasn't hard to sense some misgivings. Zimmermann, who was elected in 2001, had been in political limbo for three years, after a citywide redistricting plan bumped him out of his Sixth Ward seat.
Zimmermann sounds resigned when recounting his options for the 2005 campaign. He could stay in his longtime residence in the Phillips neighborhood and run for the Ninth Ward seat, move a few blocks away and run again in the Sixth Ward, or buy a house in another ward without an incumbent council member up for reelection.
In early February, Zimmermann and Heiser found a dream house in the new Sixth Ward, and his wife insisted it would be their new home. Politics are, after all, an art of strategic compromises. Suddenly Zimmermann was facing the prospect of running against sometime political ally Robert Lilligren, the council's vice president, who himself had seen his ward change from the Eighth to the Sixth. "I didn't necessarily want to run against Robert," Zimmermann says.
Marital bliss aside, the alternatives didn't appear more attractive. Gary Schiff, the Ninth Ward incumbent, would already be familiar to 90 percent of that constituency from the previous districting plan. (The Sixth and Ninth abut in the heart of south Minneapolis along Lake Street.) And while Zimmermann found that he had support for a potential run in the predominantly Northeast Third Ward, he likely would have had to face carpetbagger claims if he moved to the beerier side of downtown.
It's not as though Zimmermann couldn't have seen this conundrum coming. For nearly three years, two Minneapolis City Council members, Zimmermann and Natalie Johnson Lee, have had a lawsuit pending against the city over the new districts. The complaint filed in U.S. District Court lists the council's two Green Party members as lead plaintiffs, and takes issue with the redistricting plan adopted by the city in April 2002. It seems the Greens, a major party in the state since 2000, had only one rep on the closed redistricting commission. The DFL, the city's longstanding majority party, had three seats. The Republicans and the Independence Party boasted two representatives each--though neither party had a single elected official in city government. Most political wonks around town acknowledge that the redistricting amounted to yet another shameless example of gerrymandering.
It seemed less like a coincidence than a matter of design that both Zimmermann and Johnson Lee would have to face hurdles in seeking reelection. "The boundary alterations did not reflect demographic changes from the 2000 Census," the court complaint notes. "But rather [they] target wards to limit the overall power of minority populations and to attempt to limit representation by the Green Party."
(According to the suit, Johnson Lee's Fifth Ward, for example, which runs from the Near North Side to the Warehouse District, was "packed" with a constituency that is 83 percent nonwhite.)
Despite these claims, the court dismissed the case in September 2004, arguing that the new plan kept neighborhoods together. The Eighth District Court of Appeals will likely look at the case sometime this summer.
Meanwhile, the redistricting has led to the political dilemma that Zimmermann and Johnson Lee had sought to avoid: four incumbents fighting for two council seats. No one around town can recall it happening in recent memory. Johnson Lee will have to face Don Samuels (who was elected to represent the Third Ward two years ago) for the Fifth Ward office. They are the only two council members of color, and that race has become the main event in the coming council elections.
Yet the undercard between Lilligren and Zimmermann, two genuine people's politicians, is equally compelling. Both were considered part of the new left that came to City Hall in a sea change last election. Lilligren was, in 2001, a 40-year-old independent building contractor who wore a ponytail and was openly gay. Zimmermann was the 60-ish Park Board member and aging radical who had a dispute with city election officials over whether he could run with his gender-neutral nickname "Zimmerperson" on the ballot. The two, along with four other new council members and a new mayor also elected way back then, have seen their lofty talk displaced by the baser realities of running the city. Both were once seen as antiestablishment; this time around, both will be...well, established.
But established where? The Sixth, which used to encompass all of Phillips to the east and southeast, has lost a chunk of turf that used to be Zimmermann country. Now it includes a swath that was previously part of Lilligren's Eighth, and gained Loring Heights, near Stevens Square. Zimmermann enjoyed popularity among African immigrants along Lake Street and American Indians on East Franklin in the old Sixth. The new ward, however, encompasses younger, whiter, more middle-class neighborhoods--like Whittier--that might go for Lilligren. In short, the race is a toss-up.