Multiplication Problems

42 Up raises a new set of questions about Michael Apted's documentary series

It's a brilliant idea: Film the same eight people every seven years, beginning at age seven. It makes for the ultimate documentary, and a potentially revelatory gaze at the mysterious interaction between individual trajectory and social conditioning.

It's also a damn weird idea, especially now, in light of The Truman Show, Ed TV, The Real World, Behind the Music, Oprah, Jerry Springer, and all the rest of it. If you squint your eyes and look at it sideways, the Up series, which began in 1964, looks like it was the avant-garde of what would become a late-20th-century fascination (at least in the West) with documenting "real life" and magnifying it back to real people. Apart from its actual subject matter, the series itself is a curious historical document, and its subjects rather like guinea pigs. (Perhaps, in keeping with the fad, someone will one day make a documentary about the making of the documentary.) No wonder so many of the subjects have expressed discomfort with taking part. And how interesting that the child who became a documentarian himself dropped out entirely!

The series started with 7 Up, a look at class differences as expressed through the playground behavior of eight British schoolchildren. Luckily for the filmmakers--including a 22-year-old Michael Apted--the children did act out their class assignments through play. 7 Up was an act of social conscience, with a message less severe but not essentially different from Pink Floyd's in The Wall: The British class system molded children like so much ground beef. (When the announcer in 7 Up says, "Give me a child until he is 7 and I will show you the man," it sounds more like a pointed political statement than a Jesuitical truism.)

The Apted Show: The supporting players of Michael Apted's 42 Up
The Apted Show: The supporting players of Michael Apted's 42 Up

Ah, but there's something evil, stupid, and capitulating about liberal propaganda that would have us believe we're all mere victims of The System. Kind of boring, too. So Apted's series gradually became a more personal exploration of people's emotional lives through the chutes and ladders of adolescence, young adulthood, and early middle age. It's not what you'd call hard-hitting stuff, and it's less revealing than one would hope. But at least the series is humane, and--unlike Springer--it always includes class as part of the context for people's individual troubles. Also unlike Springer, every one of the participants is remarkably thoughtful.

Humane or not, the films also illuminate the power struggle between documentarian and subject, played out over and over. Judging from articles (including no fewer than three separate, lengthy pieces in the New York Times), the Up films have only become more important to Apted personally and professionally. A mostly mainstream director, Apted (Coal Miner's Daughter, Gorillas in the Mist, Nell, and, bizarrely, the latest James Bond movie) is respected but not lionized--except, perhaps, for the Up films. He has said: "When I pack it all in, I think [Up] will be my signature piece." But the films seem to give no joy to most of their subjects. In 42 Up, many of them look as uncomfortable as ever in front of the camera. And all of them, one senses, are retaining key bits of information about themselves that would help us to understand them better. The part of you that's burned out on invasive media wants to cheer for these independent people--but the truth-seeker would prefer something else.

Take Neil, arguably the most interesting of the bunch. In 21 Up, he was a vagabond in the countryside, obviously dogged by gigantic phantoms of misery and delusion. Apted did ask whether he ever feared for his sanity, but we never understood exactly what was going on. (Schizophrenia? Bipolarity? Unresolved childhood abuse?) In 42 Up, Neil surprises us with an almost supernatural renaissance of self--he's confident, self-nurturing, and productive. Obviously something major happened, and one suspects it has something to do with a crackerjack shrink and some heavenly meds. Then again, maybe not.

Or take Lynn, a working-class woman who became a children's librarian and has stayed happily married to her youthful sweetheart. She has apparently awesome kids and seemingly fulfilling work. Yet Lynn comes across as one of the most morose people in the film, uncharmed by life and no fun at all on camera. Again, we're obviously missing key info here. Does she have some horrid secret illness? Was she raped? Does she hate Michael Apted? Does she have tragically unfulfilled ambitions? Or is she just one of those people who always seem unhappy?

The guessing game only gets tougher with people's spouses. Tony, a teenage jockey who now drives a cab, seems to be married to a real sourpuss who just doesn't love her husband much, if she ever did. ("I couldn't get rid of him" was how she described their courtship in an earlier episode.) In 35 Up and 42 Up, Tony's infidelity is revealed. But you have to wonder which came first: Tony's misbehavior or his wife's awfulness. And do I feel sympathetic with this cheater because Apted does? Somehow, it sounds like a blessed sign of life when this man, who has seen his share of disappointments, explains his misstep by saying, "Life is for living."

In fact, Tony's episode is one of the more intriguing ones, partly because he's so open. (And could this have to do with his sideline ambition as an actor?) When he shows Apted his remodeled house and yard, his concern over money is obvious. One can imagine this couple believing that if they threw enough cash at their home, they might be able to salvage their family. Tony seems quietly desperate as he stands in his new back yard and says, "I think this must be the limits for me." Only the next episode will tell whether he meant the limit of his life or of his patience.

Next Page »

Now Showing

Find capsule reviews, showtimes & tickets for all films in town.

Box Office Report

Join My Voice Nation for free stuff, film info & more!